4 ms·
I'm crossing fingers for Elon Musk and SpaceX rockets. Sonic booms go parallel to your path, so a vertically moving rocket has a sonic boom that goes parallel
by btilly 9y ago
I'm crossing fingers for Elon Musk and SpaceX rockets.
Sonic booms go parallel to your path, so a vertically moving rocket has a sonic boom that goes parallel to the ground and doesn't bother anyone.
However the big issue with rockets (other than technology which SpaceX thinks that it can handle) is that about 1/3 of people get sick in freefall. (Estimate that I read from the operators of the vomit comet.)
- skykooler 9y agoThis is lower, however, when you're strapped into your seat. In the vomit comet, you're free to move about, which drastically increases the likelihood of nausea.
- ericd 9y agoThe other problem is that the BFR would carry 10 kt of fuel. Even a very small chance of that much fuel exploding anywhere near a major city is too much risk, so you'd have to put them well away from population centers. So you can tack on a couple hours to the spaceport on each end.
- Gustomaximus 9y agoLenghty travel to spaceport would tie in nicely with the hyperloop.
- ericd 9y agoGood point, that might make it more feasible. I hope we see some successful deployments.
- btilly 9y agoSpaceX's vision was a 30 min ride on a high speed catamaran. Depending on details that probably puts the landing pad something like 15-20 miles out in the ocean. Do you think that that is unreasonable?
- ericd 9y agoWell, something to consider is that Little Boy (the hiroshima bomb) had a yield of roughly 15kt. Obviously a nuke has different characteristics from a fuel-air explosion, most of which I haven't considered and would not qualified to comment on anyway, but the comparison doesn't make me very comfortable with 15 miles. It probably wouldn't be within the blast radius (depending on how the burning fuel propagated), at least, but the the amount of radiant heat generated would be nothing to sneeze at. I could certainly be overestimating the issue - I'm guessing the rapidity of a nuclear explosion vs. a fuel air explosion affects its pound for pound destructiveness significantly. Sibling comment has a good point that hyperloop could make spaceports at safe distances more accessible.
- btilly 9y agoHiroshima was total destruction within 1 mile, the farthest away that glass broke was 12 miles, no damage past that. So 15 miles is definitely out of the blast radius. What about the fireball? Google told me the following. 15 miles is roughly 24 km. The mass of air is 1.2 kg per cubic meter. The volume of a sphere is 4/3 pi r^3. The energy of a kt is about 4.184e9 joules. It takes about 1 joule to increase the temperature of air by 1 C. When I put all of that together I calculate that a 15kt explosion has enough energy to raise the temperature of a 15 mile ball of air by about 0.9 C. Please double check my figures and calculation, but I think that your average city can survive that. :-)
- ericd 9y agoHa! Thanks for running through the numbers, very interesting. The air in that 15 mile ball is almost transparent to infrared, though, so I'd probably assume that the surface area of the sphere would receive the lion's share, rather than the volume within it. So the energy delivered should fall off roughly with the square of the radius rather than the cube. Might be enough to give a sunburn, if nothing else. Edit: On my phone I'm getting ~5.8 joules per square meter. Google seems to be mangling the units, though, so I can't be sure it's not dropping or adding in a factor of 1,000, though. Edit 2: assuming that figure is correct, unless it's released in <1/200 of a second, it's not competitive with the sun at the equator (>1,000 Watts/Joules per m^2 per second)
- Already__Taken 9y agoThe F9 makes a pretty disgusting triple boom on landing so I can't see the bfr being better in that respect.
- btilly 9y agoPer SpaceX's plans, the landing would be some miles away from people. A supersonic jet makes a sonic boom on the ground over its whole trajectory. That's what makes it undesirable for overland travel.
- bllguo 9y agoWhat? Surely you mean perpendicular to the path? Or does path mean something different from trajectory..?
- btilly 9y agoI do mean perpendicular, sorry.
- Boothroid 9y agoI really want it to happen, but I'll believe it when I see it.