2 ms·
I am not a lawyer either. But I wonder what the phrase "has the right" means. If you read that as, "Has a trademark covering", they are fine because nobody ha
by btilly 16y ago
I am not a lawyer either. But I wonder what the phrase "has the right" means.
If you read that as, "Has a trademark covering", they are fine because nobody had the right. Alternately if you read that as, "Has an established history doing business as", they are fine if the existing business had not been set up yet. There are other interpretations under which they would be not so fine.
However my guess is that in the whole negotiation, there must have been discussions with actual qualified lawyers. If the original owner had a good legal case, I think that would have come up then. Therefore I'm inclined to believe that there is no legal problem.
That said, their treatment of the original owner does seem pretty bad.
- ig1 16y agoOne of the reasons I wrote up the blog post was to try and get some views from people who are trademark lawyers. We need to remember that lawyers are human too and screw up as well. How many programmers do you know who never miss things ?