7 ms·
Reads like this are slowly convincing me not to buy into the world of mortgages and debt and to just live the rest of my life paying for everything in cash. I t
by Waterluvian 9y ago
Reads like this are slowly convincing me not to buy into the world of mortgages and debt and to just live the rest of my life paying for everything in cash. I tried to buy a house last year with my wife but the market exploded where I live and suddenly houses were 40% more expensive from last year.
So we still rent, which makes me feel incomplete. Like I'm kind of failing my duty of bringing the Canadian Dream to my family. But I gotta tell you, seeing 45% of my before tax income going into savings feels amazingly liberating. I stopped calling my savings a "down payment". It's now, "two college funds and 3 years of unemployment."
I feel in total control of my future this way, but I also feel like I'm feeding into the apocalypse paranoia. I won't actually need this unemployment cash will I?
- bufordsharkley 9y agoIt's no surprise that we're seeing more and more anxiety coalesce around land: this is the classical economic expectation of what would happen as automated output starts to outperform labor, and capital can be automatically produced. When this happens, scarce natural resources (such as location) increase in value. Henry George saw this nearly 140 years ago, with his "Fool's Paradise" thought experiment.[0] As efficiency rises and rises, can the cost of living ever approach zero, or will the landlords (in their many forms) be able to extract what they will? This is a very important question we need to answer. [0] http://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/George/grgPP15.html#III.V.13 http://www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/George/grgPP15.html#...
- graeme 9y agoPlease don’t encourage the Toronto housing bubble. (Or Vancouver, OP is surely in one of the two) I’m sure Georgianism has its merits, but housing generally hasn’t been a great investment in most of north america, especially once maintenance costs are factored in. Meanwhile, Toronto and Vancouver are in the midst of a speculative housing mania. House prices have far outpaced rents. OP is correct not to buy. (Especially now, the bank regulator has just announced restrictions on mortgage lending. These are likely to reduce home prizes as average mortgage eligibility will shrink) Long run, you may be right, but re: the canadian markets OP is referring to you’re commenting on a situation of short term mania. Note: I’m referring chiefly to your “it’s no surprise” line. I’d say the cause of the immediate anxiety is the housing mania I described, rather than a longer run trend.
- jacobolus 9y agoIf we had land-value taxes plus more permissive zoning, that would add some negative feedback when land prices start rising, and discourage (or tax) speculation and rent-seeking, while encouraging productive land uses like higher-density housing which help to keep cost of living in check.
- bufordsharkley 9y agoThis is quite fair. No message to "put all your money in land!" was intended, and indeed we see many cases of localized manias, the galloping of irrational exuberance. Land bubbles come and go, but the underlying cause is the same. What's productive about bidding up the price of land, after all?
- graeme 9y agoIndeed. Also, I should say I was commenting more for Canadians reading, rather than because I thought you were for putting money in land. I’ll have to read up on Georgism. I’m very interested in alternatives to an income tax; it seems counterproductive to tax something we want to have. There are so many things with externalities we could replace it with.
- lmm 9y ago> I’m sure Georgianism has its merits, but housing generally hasn’t been a great investment in most of north america, especially once maintenance costs are factored in. Georgists would expect housing (or rather, land) prices to rise in places where productivity is increasing, and not in places where productivity isn't increasing, which seems to align with what we're seeing - economic growth is largely happening in the cities, and much less in the suburbs or countryside.
- graeme 9y agoYeah, i think in a broader sense that’s true. In Toronto and Vancouver though, prices have fast outstripped economic growth. Vancouver and Toronto aren’t particularly high income cities, relative to, say, Montreal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KKKKkkkk1 9y agoWhat? Haven't you been listening to the central banks? Inflation is abysmally low, we gotta pump up prices to get the economy going. With such low inflation, it's impossible that housing prices increased 40% within one year. /s
- Joeri 9y agoI don’t think house prices are included in the consumer price index. Most governments tie social security payouts to CPI and are therefore motivated to change the CPI calculation method to minimize the rise. If you dig down into what they actually measure all common economic indicators (GDP, PPP, CPI, ...) are B.S. They’re there to pretend that economics is a science, while in practice it’s more of an art, or a quackery, depending on your disposition.
- lostboys67 9y agoexactly I know the UK government was looking at a CPI+H but it didn't produce the figure they wanted so the ONS was told to go away and try again (source was some one who works for the ONS)
- justinjlynn 9y ago> So we still rent, which makes me feel incomplete. Like I'm kind of failing my duty of bringing the Canadian Dream to my family. To paraphrase George Carlin, they call it "the dream" because you'd have to be asleep to believe it.
- ianai 9y agoDon’t let some stereotype of supposed happiness keep you from the real thing. Further, remember cash is great. Keep that cash through to the next bubble burst and when all the prices tank pick up everything on clearance-level prices.
- hectorlorenzo 9y agoSlightly off-topic, but that is the main reason I do not want to have kids: I am not sure I would like the kind of person I would become. Sometimes I am already paralysed by fear when thoughts about my future take a dark turn (relatively often), but at the end of the day it is my well-being (and my wife's) we are talking about, and we are economically independent adults. We could take a hit or two. Throwing little defenceless creatures in the mix? Oh gosh...
- bamboozled 9y agoThis seems to be a pretty common attitude amongst a lot of people in their late twenties and early thirties I socialise with (who should probably be well into parenthood). Common question seems to be, "Why bring a child into a world facing climate change, potential nuclear war and a lack of prosperity or opportunities for personal growth". Adopting is probably a better option ;)
- toasterlovin 9y agoOn the other hand, maybe let your kids decide if life is worth living. Seems wrong to make that decision for them...
- mhb 9y agoIs it wrong to make the decision for the first 1.8 kids or the next 8-10?
- toasterlovin 9y agoSimple: as many kids as you would have if the world weren't so terrible that "it's wrong to bring them into a world like this."
- graphitezepp 9y agoYou make this decision when you have kids, not by not having them.
- lin_lin 9y agoWow that's some jump. It's the opposite for me in a way, I'm renting and it's killing me to see all that "wasted". A mortgage would cost far less than what rent is, and by paying it off I see that as a type of "investment" i.e. at least I'll four walls around me and my family.
- patrickk 9y agoDepends on what type of a property market you're buying into. If you buy at or near the peak, and a year or two later you have a massive mortgage and a property that's worth a fraction of that (knee deep in negative equity), then renting will feel a whole lot better. You might even have some savings to get a deposit on a cheap property.
- mywittyname 9y agoNot everyone lives in an area where a 30y mortgage is cheaper than rent. Even those that claim to may not have the math right (not accounting for maintenance, taxes, increases in utilities). I live in the midwest, where housing is supposed to be cheap, and the renting v. buying equation heavily favors renting when factoring in commute times. Since I'm a working professional, I'm limited to living in "working professional" neighborhoods if I want to live <20m from work. This means the median house value for the area I want to be in is over double the national median, the houses are all massive (cleaning and utility costs) and they all have HOAs of varying costs. The total savings of renting for me is solidly $12,000+ a year, in addition to saved commuting time.
- kazinator 9y agoThose that find rent cheaper than a 30y mortgage also may not have all the math right. They may be looking at instantaneous rent prices, not accounting for rental increases over 30 years (while the mortgage will remain relatively flatlined, modulo ups and downs in interest). When I started my mortgage in 2010, it was a bit more expensive than renting in my area. Not so any more. Comparable places now rent for hundreds of dollars more per month than what I pay in total. Mortgages have some flexibilities in them. What landlord offers "skip a payment"? Haha. One little thing that isn't a matter of all that much money is that renters often live without home insurance, quite unnecessarily. Even if you live in someone's home which has homeowner insurance, the policy doesn't cover the personal belongings of renters; if the place is destroyed, you lose everything in it with no compensation, unless you have your own policy. It costs like a couple hundred bucks a year.
- lhopki01 9y agoThis depends on where you live? In London monthly rent is higher than the cost of paying for a mortgage so it makes financial sense have a mortgage even if the final sale price of the house is 0.
- alien_at_work 9y agoDon't feel bad about renting. In german real estate is called "Immobilien". And it is, I saw an investor somewhere put down some actual math and buying a house tends to be a bad investment compared to what could have been done, largely because of illiquidity of it. >seeing 45% of my before tax income going into savings feels amazingly liberating. By "savings" I hope you mean an ETF or mutual fund. If you do that you should stop calling it "3 years of unemployment" and start calling it "early retirement".
- Waterluvian 9y agoUnder my mattress! Kidding. A combination of TFSA max out, RRSP max out, rolling GIC, RESP. I doubt I'm min-maxing my savings ideally, but I'm generally interested in infinitesimal risk solutions I don't have to think about more than once a quarter or so. I've only been in the workforce for 4 years. Married for 1. Was planning on a house so I valued liquidity. But you're right, I need to do the mature, responsible thing and actually do some financial planning. I just really hate money and want to not think about it.
- alien_at_work 9y agoThat's exactly what index funds are for: just dump what you can spare into it every pay period and don't even look at the statement. When you get to, say, mid 50's, have a look to see if you can retire. My advise, when you're ready to give a little thought to this is to check out this site: [1]. EDIT: After you pick out some indexes (at you're age I'd probably just do SP500 exclusively), you can use this [2] to see what that could look like over a given time frame. Normal disclaimers apply: past performance does not gaurentee future success, etc. but it can give you a good idea of what will probably happen. I'd advise picking a date before the financial crisis so you can see how little these "end of the world" events actually matter over 30+ year horizons. [1] https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios [2] https://www.portfoliovisualizer.com/backtest-portfolio https://www.portfoliovisualizer.com/backtest-portfolio
- hectorlorenzo 9y ago
- csomar 9y agoAre you planning to live in that big dream house all of your life? I have seen it through my parents. They saved money hard till I reached 12-13 where they were able to afford the "house". But guess what, at my 20, pretty much everyone left the house. And now they are staying in this "big empty house" that is expensive as hell to run. The alternative could have been to rent out a nice vila while we were young. It would have been then an expensive "few years" instead.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- et-al 9y ago(random aside: which city had its housing prices jump like that? Waterloo?)
- Waterluvian 9y agoYup.