3 ms·
This is a toxic attitude. You say that some prisoners will never be rehabilitated and say they won't become Georgetown law professors. This ignores the possib
by mulmen 9y ago
This is a toxic attitude.
You say that some prisoners will never be rehabilitated and say they won't become Georgetown law professors. This ignores the possibility that they could become something better than a prisoner. Note that the comment you replied to did not claim that all prisoners should be Georgetown law professors.
You admit that prisoners could have better outcomes with encouragement then make unfair generalizations that reinforce our alarming incarceration rate.
This is a huge cultural problem in the United States and we need to start being honest with ourselves about these biases.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoHonest about what biases? My claim is it's unlikely that a prisoner will be a Georgetown law professor, which is a statistical fact. I had an uncle die in prison, I've known people that were in and out of prison. I don't judge them on that, but there's not an insignificant number that's not really capable of reform and ended up back in jail due to their own personal issues. Some of course, do change. I'd like a better society, too, but change is based in reality, and if reality is "biased", it's not gonna do you any good to ignore it.
- mulmen 9y agoWe're talking past each other. I don't think anyone is making the claim that prisoners should be Georgetown law professors. The point here is that the story shows prisoners have a lot more potential than we give them credit for. If we considered the potential for redemption instead of fixating on why the person is wasted we could make the world better for everyone. The bias I am alluding to is the assumption that prisoners cannot be redeemed. The reality is that our criminal justice system does not do a good job of rehabilitating people because it is focused on punishment.