4 ms·
> or preventing bomb attacks You're more likely to die by falling down the stairs than by being killed by a terrorist[0]. Bomb attacks are not something you sh
by jstanley 9y ago
> or preventing bomb attacks
You're more likely to die by falling down the stairs than by being killed by a terrorist[0]. Bomb attacks are not something you should be concerned by.
However much bomb attacks scare you, you should be ~100x more scared of living in a house that has more than one floor.
[0] http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/12/just-dangerous-terrorism-really.html http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/12/just-dangerous-terror...
- alva 9y agoThis argument is repeated ad nauseam and a bit of thinking on distribution and magnitude of risk will show you why it is nonsense in this context.
- jstanley 9y agoEnlighten us?
- alva 9y agoRisks of day-to-day activities are known, their distribution effectively fixed and the magnitude of the risk also understood. The probability of ladder falls tripling year-to-year is of order 10^-14. I understand that driving my car could potential result in my death. There is some variability in the risk depending on how careful I am, time of day, whether I am sober etc, and of course risk out of my hands from other road users. I can have a good understanding of the risk and factor that in whether to carry out a daily activity. War and Terrorism is completely different. When they occur is unknown, whether the event is small or cataclysmic unknown, the secondary effects they have in a wide complex system unknown. You can take the original argument even further to understand why it is silly. Atomic bombs have only been used against people twice, therefore the chance of you dying in a car crash are multi-million times higher than dying from an atomic bomb. Should there not be an intense focus on de-proliferation, de-escalation of conflicts because of this? The consequences of an nuclear attack are so great, we spend huge amount of resources to reduce the likelihood. Terrorism is similar. It is not only the poor victims of the attack who suffer. Our societies function on a fairly fine balance, much of which is predicated on the ability of our governance to keep us safe. Rapidly increasing frequency of attacks and their effectiveness drive us closer to instability and can severely damage our economies. You dying in a car crash is going to hurt your friends and loved ones. You being blown up along with 50 passengers on the underground, the fifth explosion that week can have dramatic and scary results for us all.
- jstanley 9y ago> Should there not be an intense focus on de-proliferation, de-escalation of conflicts because of this? Sure, nuclear disarmament wouldn't hurt, but like you said: atomic bombs have only been used against people twice. There's no evidence that their use against people is likely to substantially increase over the next few years, so it's not something that is worth worrying about. Just like terrorism. EDIT: And certainly it is not worth using the risk of atomic bombs as an excuse to invade the privacy and erode the freedoms of millions of people.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoDo you think I'm correct in believing terrorism is likely to increase over the next few years?
- jstanley 9y agoNo? Do you believe that?
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoSome sources claim the number of people who have died from terrorist activity has increased ninefold since the year 2000[1]. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-11-17/global-terrorism-index-increase/6947200 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-11-17/global-terrorism-index...
- alva 9y ago> There's no evidence that their use against people is likely to substantially increase over the next few years, so it's not something that is worth worrying about It does not even matter whether there is evidence that the risk is likely to increase or not. Plus, it is arguable unknowable what the current risk may be now or in a few years time (plus, do you really trust NK's safety in chain of command and equipment?). Regardless, no matter how unlikely the event is to occur the magnitude or the event is so unbelievably massive that is something to be worthy of worrying about. It all comes downs to understanding that despite a extremely low probability of occurring, some events are so earth shattering, you cannot discount it by its probability of happening. On September 10th there was no evidence an attack on New York City was particularly likely (apart from in the minds of the terrorists). But September 11th came along and changed the West and Middle East for decades.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI'm sooooooooo sick of this argument. It's not that it's incorrect from a probabilistic point of view, but it shows such an indifference to the facts of how humans actually are rather than how they should be as ideal rational actors. Look, what are the odds of being killed by a spider? tiny. And most spiders aren't even poisonous. But lots of people have an irrational phobia of creepy crawly animals, perhaps due to some unpleasant childhood experience. If someone is afflicted with such a phobia, maybe therapy can help them, maybe they'll grow out of it, whatever, but standing around saying 'it's very irrational of you to be scared of this probably harmless spider' is no help whatsoever. Either get rid of the spider for them or leave them alone, because when someone is freaking out they're not able to process information rationally. We know that people don't react rationally to real risk probabilities, some are irrationally risk averse and others are irrationally risk tolerant. We know that such irrational cognitive behaviors are often exploited by unscrupulous actors to manipulate people for financial, political, or strategic gain. We know that the externalities of such exploitation impinge upon our economy, liberty and so so on. Endlessly repeating an argument that people are already demonstrably indifferent to isn't getting us anywhere. Education is one long-term approach to alleviating that problem but it's very slow and expensive and outcomes are hard to predict and to measure. It has consistently proven easier for politicians to spend money on security services (both pragmatic and theatrical) than it has to raise the intelligence/wisdom of the public at large.
- KGIII 9y agoI think it is a silly argument in the first place. See, they are additional preventable deaths, and not accidental. Comparing them is pretty silly. That said, I still don't like reductions in liberties due to fear of terrorism. Freedom is inherently risky. I am not a coward. Giving up liberties out of fear is not necessarily a good idea.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI heartily agree but have yet to see a country where the response to foreign-originated terrorism isn't to either lash out or get paranoid.