6 ms·
This is an interesting hack. According to sources Airbus gets 50.1% of the Class C jet's "business", in exchange for building them in a pre-existing plant in Al
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
This is an interesting hack. According to sources Airbus gets 50.1% of the Class C jet's "business", in exchange for building them in a pre-existing plant in Alabama so that they are immune to the 300% tariff that the US was planning to impose (considering to impose?) on them.
The hack allows Bombardier to recoupe its design costs by selling planes. They will no doubt get less margin selling them through Airbus but it is better that having to flush that investment down the tubes.
- tareqak 9y agoIt might benefit Bombardier and their investors, but if the C series jet was going to be manufactured in Canada by Canadian workers, this ends up harming those (potential?) jobs in favour of American workers who previously never had any sort of relationship with Bombardier. To me, the whole situation is a schoolyard example of "having your cake and eating it too".
- sf_rob 9y agoThe alternative may have been "having no cake" since they would not be profitable without successfully fighting the 300% tariff.
- tareqak 9y agoI actually agree. To clarify my position further, I am specifically accusing the United States and Boeing as the ones who are trying to "have their cake and eat it too" in this matter.
- cloakandswagger 9y agoIs there something inherently wrong with looking out for your own best interests? Or in this case, the best interests of your country?
- UnoriginalGuy 9y agoSo by extension you'd be happy if the EU imposed a 300% tax on Boeing imports? Even if it meant Americans lost jobs. That's what this attitude results in: trade war.
- andy_ppp 9y agoYes, the whole point of free trade means that we can buy the best mobile phones or the best computer chips or the best washing machines. Without free markets you end up having worse products win which is bad for everyone.
- kpil 9y agoA particular line of economics just looks at the money in, the product out, ignores all complications, and concludes that it's globally best for mankind if we send money on ships and get back cheap sneakers, regardless if they are made by slave workers or whatever. It's not only the quality of the products that compete, it's living standards, health laws, worker protection, environmental protection, social welfare, healthcare, educations and human rights that compete. If I live in a (economically) large enough country that trades with another country that fail providing reasonable levels of all of the above for their own people, mostly to the gain of some oligark or another, there is little reason to offer totally free trade. An optimal tariff, possibly even invested back in the originating country - or even used to fund healthcare or education - is most likely globally less maximized in term of number of cheap items per dollar, but could still help stimulate both economies, maybe help the poorest, and hopefully avoiding a race to the bottom for the 99%. [edit]... This doesn't mean that a 300% tariff on airplanes is justified between EU, US and Canada. Or maybe we in EU can fund your healthcare if you just buy from Airbus in the future...
- cbhl 9y ago> It's not only the quality of the products that compete, it's living standards, health laws, worker protection, environmental protection, social welfare, healthcare, educations and human rights that compete. Canada has single-payer ("free") health care, and plans to introduce a national carbon tax. There's a narrow socio-economic gap in school results[0]. Tell me again how the United States has better health care, environmental protection, and education? [0] http://www.bbc.com/news/business-40708421 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-40708421
- wrnu 9y agoIt seems like only the planes bound for US airlines will be manufactured in the US.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThis is, I think, the key feature. While the US does consume a bunch of planes, it is by no means the only market. What Delta did for Bombardier was to give them a 'light house' customer[1] to show the world that this plane was worth considering. [1] The 'light house customer' metaphor was a favorite of Chris Bennet's at NetApp. They were a customer that if they adopted your product, others in the same business would see your product as a "safe harbor" and would be willing to buy your stuff too. The unwillingness to be 'first' in an industry where one plane represents a big chunk of capital is strong.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoI figured that Swissair was that lighthouse customer. They've had very positive feedback for the C-series, which is quite impressive for a brand new model. Honestly I doubt Delta would've even considered the C-series if they were to be the first major customer.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt does look like Lufthansa/Swissair was the earlier 'major' customer, although this graph (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Bombardier_CSeries_orders_and_deliveries#Orders.2C_commitments_.26_deliveries_graph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Bombardier_CSeries_ord...) shows why Boeing complained about Delta :-)
- inferiorhuman 9y agoIMO the big reason that Boeing is going after BBD is not the CS100, but the prospect of a CS500 which would compete directly with the antiquated 737. Boeing has, for now, left Embraer alone because the E2 can't be stretched as much as the C-series. The hypocrisy is strong with Boeing though. Boeing's received over $8 billion in tax breaks (errrr subsidies) from the state of Washington alone. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/boeings-historic-tax-break-from-state-even-bigger-than-thought/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/boeings-historic-t...
- netsharc 9y agoA Guardian article https://www.theguardian.com/business/nils-pratley-on-finance/2017/oct/17/airbuss-ingenious-bombardier-plan-is-comeuppance-for-boeing https://www.theguardian.com/business/nils-pratley-on-finance... says: > Arch-rival Airbus has swooped from the wings to grab majority control of the C-Series and proclaim that the 300% tariffs can be side-stepped via the simple remedy of conducting the final assembly of planes destined for US customers in Alabama. So, how much of a final assembly counts as final assembly? I remember a story of how Chinese shirtmakers circumvented tariffs against Made in China shirts: they sent the body of the shirt and sleeves to Hong Kong, workers in Hong Kong sewed the sleeves onto the shirt, slap "Made in Hong Kong" on it, and problem solved... Apparently I'm not the one asking this question: http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-airbus-bombardier-deal-20171017-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-airbus-bombard... > "There is a legal question of how much of the parts and components and value-added needs to actually happen in the U.S. for tariffs to no longer apply," said Chad Bown, a senior fellow with the Peterson Institute for International Economics. "You can't just fly an airplane to Alabama and say it's made in America."
- usrusr 9y agoWhen in doubt, apply the magic of cross-site IP licencing to coax the value-add distribution into whatever shape necessary.
- pingec 9y agoPipistrel from Slovenia had a similar problem. IIRC they had to ship parts to USA/Australia and assemble them over there. Now they moved part of production to Italy and this seems to have circumvented some of these problems.
- ecommerceguy 9y agoEmbraer (Brazil) does final assembly of their private jet line in Melbourne Florida. I toured the factory. How it works is the fuselage is boated from Brazil and then assembled in FL. Wiring, hydraulics ect all done in Fl. Perhaps a peek at their public statements can shed some light as to when the nexus occurs.
- pasbesoin 9y ago
- jpollock 9y agoMy expectation is that C-series jets for the US market would be produced in the US, planes for Europe are probably better produced in Canada to make use of the Canada/EU FTA. From the article: "a second assembly line for the 100- to 150-seat plane will be set up at Airbus's facility in Mobile, Ala., so the plane can be sold in the United States" By the way, I'm convinced that a big reason that small car manufacturing has moved to Mexico is the list of free trade agreements they have.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cacti 9y agoYou isn't a game you can "hack" with a clever trick. Even if it got around a law (which it doesn't), Congress would just write a new one. This doesn't change anything.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Even if it got around a law (which it doesn't), Congress would just write a new one. This doesn't change anything. The Congress wrote the law, at Boeing's behest, to encourage American manufacturing employment. Airbus and Bombardier's deal sounds an awful lot like it accomplishes that.
- Cacti 9y agoThis has nothing to do with this US employment. This is a trade 'war'. The issue is dumping, subsidies, and foreign competition. Whether the plane is temporarily assembled in the US or not is irrelevant.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> This has nothing to do with this US employment The Department of Commerce announced its affirmative preliminary determination in respect of Bombardier's alleged dumping under its countervailing duties (CVD) powers from the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, as amended [1][2]. The Tariff Act was passed "to protect American jobs and farmers from foreign competition" [2]. There is a secondary concern in national security, e.g. if a country's automotive sector is decimated by foreign competition then it can no longer build tanks. But the driving concern behind "trade wars," and certainly this administration's enforcement of them, is employment. [1] http://enforcement.trade.gov/download/factsheets/factsheet-canada-large-civil-aircraft-ad-prelim-100617.pdf http://enforcement.trade.gov/download/factsheets/factsheet-c... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot–Hawley_Tariff_Act#End_of_the_tariffs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot–Hawley_Tariff_Act#End_of...
- Cacti 9y agoYou realize that the justification for the action and the reason behind it need not be the same thing, right? The fact that they are citing a law that was, nearly 100 years ago, concerned with employment, doesn’t mean that is why they are doing this. This is a long term strategic calculation and has nothing to do with a few thousand jobs.
- alexasmyths 9y agoDouble benefit - the ownership may have come from the Canadian government, meaning the Canadian government is no longer 'subsidising' the carrier.