4 ms·
> Are American courts ready for those sorts of questions? In short, no, and they never will be. Courts aren't supposed to be in the business of solving social
by wahern 9y ago
> Are American courts ready for those sorts of questions?
In short, no, and they never will be. Courts aren't supposed to be in the business of solving social issues. Their fundamental function is to adjudicate disputes where there has been concrete, identifiable, and remediable harm to one individual by another individual.
Remember that in a gerrymandering case the fundamental question is whether a _specific_ plaintiff has been _specifically_ harmed by gerrymandering. The best statistical model in the world isn't going to answer that question; at best it gets you halfway there.
The executive and legislative branches are supposed to be the organs of government that grapple with these issues; the ones that enlist legions of bureaucrats to aggregate data and decide on the best aggregate policies. The real issue is that we're asking too much of our courts because the other two branches of our government--especially the legislative branch--has become ineffective and derelict. And, yes, that's party because of gerrymandering. It's quite a dilemma, but that still doesn't mean that the courts should jump into the fray.
I'm skeptical of conservative arguments that courts should stay completely out of gerrymandering disputes. It's obviously self-serving, not to mention hypocritical in light of the fact that all the conservative justices wanted to strike-down non-partisan redistricting commissions as unconstitutional. But as a clear legal rule that approach has significant benefits. Among other things, it would force communities to return to the ballot box rather than resort to the courthouse.