5 ms·
When everyone is in an index fund, the market becomes less efficient and several profitable opportunities are overlooked (and conversely, failing companies take
by nostrademons 9y ago
When everyone is in an index fund, the market becomes less efficient and several profitable opportunities are overlooked (and conversely, failing companies take longer to be recognized as failing). That means bigger returns for active investors who are both confident and right. Eventually the market equilibrates as people start realizing certain active investors are consistently beating the market and shift cash from index funds into their funds.
It's unlikely to result in a crash, though, rather a period of sustained underperformance and a few people getting fantastically wealthy. You could argue that the tech-billionaire phenomena is the primary capital markets example of this: there's a widespread belief that founding a new business is foolhardy and you're better off working for an established company, so people who buck this belief and are right end up making a lot of money off it, which draws a lot of people away from employment and into entrepreneurship, which drives down average returns to entrepreneurship as most of the new startups wash out and fail to beat the market.
- AstralStorm 9y agoWell, it can be foolhardy depending on how much you gamble and how competitive and with how high barriers of entry the market you want to compete in is. Also how local. Real economics are never quite as easy as a single equation. A more proper model would be similar to weather modelling.