3 ms·
He thought seed:leech ratios were a dumb idea, creating an artificial scarcity where none was needed. You can't save bandwidth for later. The idea is to get us
by icebraining 9y ago
He thought seed:leech ratios were a dumb idea, creating an artificial scarcity where none was needed. You can't save bandwidth for later.
The idea is to get users to seed, rather than just leach and then shut off their client. Where does saving bandwidth come into the picture?
- simias 9y agoI always thought it was a pretty silly system too. You end up in a situation where you want do download something, other people want to upload that thing but you don't do it because you don't want to ruin your ratio. This in turns means that these other people don't increase their ratios and end up in the same situation. You have an artificial 0-sum game for absolutely no good reason. Then you need freeleech periods or bonuses to make up for the ratio credit "deflation". I think it would make more sense to punish people who never seed (seeding if nobody is downloading is fine, you can't do anything about it) and incite people to seed torrents with a low seed count.
- icebraining 9y agoI agree. In the only private tracker I use, you get rewarded for both the amount you've seeded and also for the number of torrents you're seeding (even if nobody downloads them).
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI guess I'm socially inept both in real life and on the Internet, because I never figured out, how do you get on a private tracker?
- simias 9y agoDepends on the trackers, most of the time you need an invite. Private trackers are often topical, either focusing on movies, video games, music, ebooks etc... So if you want an invite to these you just need to hang out with people who share these interests and then ask around. IRC is a good place to start in my experience. Some semi-private trackers also have periods where registration is open to all.
- icebraining 9y agoSome trackers have periods in which they have open registrations; there are a few sites which track these (like r/OpenSignups), so I subscribed to one and registered to those that seemed interesting. Otherwise, you have to get an invite by an existing user; if you don't know any, I think the best bet is to lurk forums and IRC channels and beg for one. I never actually went that route, though.
- darklajid 9y agoWhat.cd was one of those - you literally had to get an invite from friends (inept as you that didn't work for me) or apply via IRC (can do that!), including an interview to make sure that you understood the rules and had a basic understanding of audio formats, encoding parameters. People that brought you on were supposedly responsible for any problem you caused..
- ConfucianNardin 9y agoRedacted (like the late What.CD, which it aims to replace) has interviews (https://interviewfor.red/en/index.html https://interviewfor.red/en/index.html). Most private trackers requires an invite (from someone who is already a member and has invite privileges) though.
- rtpg 9y agoOne person seeding a really popular file once will now be able to download a bunch of other files without seeding. But this isn't actually the most usrful result! In this model distributing 100MB of GoT is as valuable as distributing 100MB of some file with only 2 or 3 seeders. But those Megs are not equivalent if the objective is to maximize availability of files. Being the seeder of last resort on a rarely (but still downloaded!) file is way more valuable than being the 100k'th seeder on some new TV show. This isn't necessarily what the GP was getting at but is a good example of seed ratios not having the best incentives.
- alphaalpha101 9y agoAnd being the first seeder of a GoT is immensely valuable and should be rewarded heavily by the system, if not by the legal system.
- ConfucianNardin 9y agoAnd this is why many trackers have departed from purely ratio-based requirements. A couple examples: "Required ratio" based on percentage of "snatched" (i.e. downloaded) torrents you are seeded. For example, if you're seeding all torrents you have ever downloaded, your required can be 0 (instead of initially common values of 1 or 0.9). Ratioless: no ratio requirements, but you must instead seed all torrents for a specified time. Among people involved in private torrent communities it's fairly well-known that a purely ratio-based system does not provide the best incitements (which would be a library of content that is as diverse and well-seeded as possible). Anyway, the main reason many prefer private trackers to public is not only because of enforcement of contributing back, but because of rules that ensure that the available content has high quality (i.e. curation).
- CamelCaseName 9y agoOne way some trackers combat this is with bonus points that are awarded based on how poorly seeded a torrent is. (Poorly seeded torrent -> More bonus points)
- TylerE 9y ago
- cgag 9y agoThe economics of most private torrent sites is fucked beyond belief if you haven't participated. I've only seen one paper on it from Microsoft research. Maybe more has been written on it that I haven't seen.
- matthewbauer 9y agoPlease include the link if you can find it!
- CamelCaseName 9y agoHere you go! https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/dime.pdf https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/...