3 ms·
That sounds like saying "well, if you only care for Russia, Ivan the Terrible is surely an appropriate term, but he wasn't particularly terrible for Africa or A
by smsm42 9y ago
That sounds like saying "well, if you only care for Russia, Ivan the Terrible is surely an appropriate term, but he wasn't particularly terrible for Africa or Americas, so using this nickname betrays you are exclusively interested in only Russian history and don't care about the rest, otherwise you'd call him Ivan the Fourth Vasilyevich!". Doesn't sound very convincing to me.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoYou're arguing from a position of someone with some history knowledge, which is not the problem. Knowing that Ivan the Terrible was a Russian Tsar is uncommon, and if he comes up you probably will be exclusively focused on Russian history. People don't know a ton about the Dark Ages either, but "Rome collapsed leading to the Dark Ages," and "The Discovery of America/the Renisance/The Scientific Revolution led us out of the Dark Ages" are often things you will have heard. And given the context you can hear them, it's not clearly referring to Western Christian Europe.
- pwinnski 9y agoThat non-historians often misunderstand the shape and scope of the Dark Ages doesn't seem like a problem of definition, but of widespread ignorance. People who elevate the discovery of America, the renaissance, or the scientific revolution to the degree you describe are not going to be dissuaded by any sort of renaming, because those views aren't factually based in the first place.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoI started this off by saying it was one piece of a much wider problem. Calling it the Dark Ages can make your ignorance seem correct in a way that other names don't. Calling them the Early Middle Ages gets rid of the false narrative of later events ending the Dark Ages, and it doesn't accidentally imply nothing happened anywhere. It's not going to end ignorance, just remove confusion. What reason is there to keep calling it the Dark Ages? As for the isolated demand for rigor, I would not expect most people to know anything about the examples given. If I were talking about them, I would immediately add a qualifier explaining what they are. The Dark Ages are a more common term, being widely used outside of history.
- smsm42 9y agoIf you're discussing Dark Ages without even knowing the term pertains to Western Europe, renaming is not going to help. Use of the terms always implies at least basic knowledge of the context, otherwise productive communication is impossible. If you talk about commutative groups and don't even know this is a mathematical term, complaining about it being misleading is useless - either get some math background or talk about something else :) Yes, some folks in US and Europe think "history" and "Western European history" is the same thing, at least until America was "discovered". But renaming Dark Ages is not going to change this, only better education is going to change it.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoYes, changing the name will not solve the larger problem I mentioned. Better education would be necessary, but even as someone with a strong interest in history I doubt the overall value of more forced history in schools. Changing the name at least clears up confusion that can stem from ignorance of the subject. An apt mathematical comparison is infinity. Most people have heard of it, but their idea of what it is and why it's important is lacking. Some people still think about it and talk about it though. Being wrong about infinity doesn't run into the same problems as the Dark Ages though, just stoner philosophy and crackpot theories of perpetual motion.