3 ms·
You don't need to invoke this sacred "justice" to accomplish any of this, though. Your latter example of putting the insane away so as not to harm others, falls
by Jach 16y ago
You don't need to invoke this sacred "justice" to accomplish any of this, though. Your latter example of putting the insane away so as not to harm others, falls under my first category of "preventing repeated offenses" and keeps them from causing further harm. (On a side-note, I think more attempts should be made at rehabilitation, but the stigmas around mental health aren't that much better today than decades ago.)
Again, with contracts, we have already decided that contracts are good and breaking them is bad. (But not in all cases!) By punishing, or putting a wrong right, is done to encourage this assumption of contracts being good and useful.
If we standardize on usefulness and in fuzzier cases "goodness", I think that's a step forward from this notion of Justice.
I suspect we may have a simple disagreement over the meaning of the word, and less so on the actual details, but that's all the more reason to go away from it. My usage of justice can be invoked to justify sentencing a murderer 50 years after the fact to death, and I don't see how that's useful or good at all given he's just a normal guy by then.