3 ms·
What do you think about the role of Christianity in the decline of Western Europe after the Western empire fell? The Church was very powerful. And there was an
by mirimir 9y ago
What do you think about the role of Christianity in the decline of Western Europe after the Western empire fell? The Church was very powerful. And there was an absolute focus on "spiritual life", with physical reality considered as just an illusion.
- nl 9y agoInterestingly, the linked article has a (made-up) image relevant to your question. Search for the caption: "Pictured: one way to politicize this discussion; not recommended"
- mirimir 9y agoWell, made up graphic or not, the idea strikes me as rather plausible. Also, it's about religion, not politics.
- nl 9y agoit's about religion, not politics define:politicize cause (an activity or event) to become political in character. But good luck with that theory anyway!
- mirimir 9y agoNo, I made it about religion. And religion <> politics. Except to the bloody Midieval Christians, anyway. Which is a key aspect of the argument. But anyway, de gustibus non disputandum est :)
- nl 9y agoAnd religion <> politics. Except to the bloody Midieval Christians, anyway The loss of most of the Eastern Roman Empire and the defeat of the Persian Empire by a religious-based empire at around the same time indicates this "exception" may not be quite as universal as you seem to believe.
- mirimir 9y agoFair enough. I should have said something like "followers of dogmatic religions". I'm greatly amused, by the way, that modern fundamentalist Christians and Muslims agree that Jesus will return for Armageddon. And just disagree about whose side he'll be on.
- smsm42 9y agoExperience shows there is a wide range of behavior available to adherents of the same religion, and adopted by them. Saying, for example, one is a Christian, says virtually nothing about one's behavior - Christians participated in crusades, Christians burned people at stake, Christians refused to even touch weapons, Christians founded major pieces of modern physics and mathematics, Christians owned slaves, Christians actively participated in abolitionist movement... It is not a good predictor of behavior. And thus, hypothesis that their behavior is explained by their religion sounds extremely weak. It's like saying Romance and Germanic languages are bad because (many) people in Europe spoke Romance and Germanic languages and they had Dark Ages, so clearly these two are related, while in China nobody spoke these languages and they were just fine. Clearly the theory sounds just as plausible?
- mirimir 9y agoI'm not considering behavior of individuals. Rather, I'm considering how Medieval society was dominated by the Catholic Church. To me, that seems utterly undeniable.
- nl 9y agoAn alternate explanation is that medieval Europe split into multiple small conflicting areas of influence, each of which was trading economic, military and religious influence against the others. In this explanation, the Church was merely one player, and it wasn't the religious nature in itself which led to the lack of progress. Instead, it was the inward-looking nature of all of Western Europe which meant all players were more interested in gaining influence within that closed sphere rather than growth (Perhaps the reign of Charlemagne is an exception here). There are numerous examples of this kind of behavior: the sack of Constantinople by the Crusaders in 1204 is probably outside the period of time usually classed as the "dark ages" but is still a good example of this behavior.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, thanks. That makes sense to me. I'm pretty much in the Hawking/Dawkins camp regarding religion, I must admit. Edit: Quoting Hawking, from the Wikipedia article on the conflict thesis: "There is a fundamental difference between religion, which is based on authority, [and] science, which is based on observation and reason. Science will win because it works." That was obvious to me when I was 12.
- comicjk 9y agoThis is a pet peeve of mine - you're mixing Christianity with Platonism. In the Roman Empire, it was Plato and his intellectual descendants who had the idea that reality was an illusion. Christianity was influenced by this, but only somewhat, because it's a core Christian teaching that the saved will enjoy eternal, bodily life ("I believe in the resurrection of the body and life everlasting"). If you believe that reality is an illusion, like a Buddhist, this form of eternity would be a bad thing, not a good one. More specifically answering the historical question, the Church was just as strong in the Eastern Roman Empire as in the fallen West, so its presence does not really distinguish the one (lasted until 1453) from the other (Dark Age).
- mirimir 9y agoOK, but was it the same Church in the East and West? Or, even if nominally the same Church, were their attitudes about science the same?
- comicjk 9y agoThey were the same Church throughout the Dark Ages, until 1054. The treatment a person would get from the Church depended on the politics of the local bishop more than anything else. In general, the "conflict thesis" - that the Church was opposed to science as such- is no longer believed by historians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_thesis#Modern_views https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_thesis#Modern_views There are few examples of scientists being persecuted, and these few were also involved in politics, which was cutthroat for everyone.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, thanks. But it's not just about outright opposition, I think. During that period, didn't Islamic civilization generally support science more than Christian civilization did?
- chewz 9y agoQuite the opposite. The Church (mostly monasteries) in Northern Europe was the main source of progress in science and the progress was rapid. Mostly applied science though like agriculture, melioration, construction, metal forging, waterwheeel etc. This book explains quite well how Western European civilization during Dark Ages was sucking all kinds of inventions and improving them slowly in order to adapt itself in hostile conditions of Northern Europe. https://www.amazon.com/Cathedral-Forge-Waterwheel-Technology-Invention-ebook/dp/B003P2WOAE https://www.amazon.com/Cathedral-Forge-Waterwheel-Technology...