6 ms·
Hayek points out that you wouldn't choose an inflationary currency. He relies on that to limit overall inflation. But you also don't have the deflationary probl
by DennisP 9y ago
Hayek points out that you wouldn't choose an inflationary currency. He relies on that to limit overall inflation. But you also don't have the deflationary problems of the gold standard, since it's possible to make more money at will if you need it.
Regarding payments: suppose we were starting from scratch, with two proposed systems: (1) user signs transactions that authorize transfers with specific recipients and amounts, or (2) user gives multiple parties enough information to withdraw unlimited amounts, hoping unauthorized parties don't get hold of it, and we make up for the inevitable thefts with statistical antifraud protection, manual intervention, and banks just eating the losses.
I can't imagine anyone choosing the second option.
- monkmartinez 9y agoYou're proposing a false dichotomy regarding payments... As if the cryptocurrency way has no flaws and the other is chalk full of them. If life has taught us anything it is that; Given things of value, people will find a way to defraud, game or otherwise manipulate said items of value. I am positive that people will abuse or are abusing the cryptosystems to the same extent people abuse fiat given more time.
- DennisP 9y agoI'm not saying that at all, and fiat payment security is improving. But the very fact that it's able to improve implies that some systems are more secure than others.
- simias 9y ago>suppose we were starting from scratch "What-ifs" are always an interesting game but practically we're veeeery far from starting from scratch with the economy. But okay, I'll play. >user signs transactions that authorize transfers with specific recipients and amounts Great, but you've only secured one tiny part of the "earn money/spend money" loop. What if the service/goods you buy turns out to be a scam or something defective? What if my company stops paying me? What if the government starts unfairly taxing me and threatens to throw me in jail if I don't comply? Our current economy is a lot more than just adding a value on one counter while decrementing an other. It's a complex web of laws, regulations and arbitrations that mean that I can buy something on Amazon without having to cross my fingers that I'll get what I paid for. That's where this whole libertarian wet dream collapses for me. The whole argument behind bitcoin seems to be "what if your government turns into a fascist state, do you really want them to control your money?" And clearly the answer is no, but if we end up in this situation my savings account might not be the first of my worries. Nor would having my money in bitcoins prevent me from being thrown in jail if I refuse to yield my secret keys to the neo-gestapo. On the other hand if the government is benevolent and works for the good of the people then I really want it to be able to control the currency, be able to cease the money generated by illegal activities and tax legitimate income fairly in order to build roads, hospitals, schools, the police and firestations (amongst other things). I don't want to live in a society where I can't trust my democratically elected government. So maybe we should work on fixing that rather than coming up with incomplete workarounds. "Hey, my sister got detained for thought crime yesterday, but at least I can send her Bitcoins to prison unhindered! Take that Ür-Hitler!"
- rothbardrand 9y agoThat's not the whole argument, by a long shot. The dollar has lost %99.99 of its value, and in my opinion has had %100 inflation in the past 10 years (not each year but over the decade) so is effectively half as valuable again. This is theft from the people. Even Keynes recognized this. Bitcoin is an exit from that system. It has lot of other features like the ability to send money across borders which is harder to surveil and stuff like that. I'm also tired of people rationalizing taxes by talking about things like roads which get almost no money-- taxes pay for dropping bombs on brown people. That's the vast majority of where the money goes. If you're pro-tax, you're pro-murdering brown people. fullstop.
- simias 9y agoTFA points out that it's true that the dollar lost 99% of its value over the last century. "However, if you held your money in anything interest-bearing, including short-term Treasury bills with no-credit-risk, you’ve at least almost doubled the purchasing power of your money!" I'm not sure I agree with the argument that inflation is theft from the people, or at least we have to define what's "the people". Poor people who earn their salary and spend most of it within the month are not really victims of the inflation unless their wage doesn't increase proportionately with the inflation year after year. And while it's not a perfect match, salaries now are definitely not what they were in 1920. A quick google gives the average salary in 1920 at $1236 although I can't seem to find a decent source for that. Clearly the workforce's purchasing power did not collapse during the past century. "The people" who are losing money are wealthy folks (or "whales" in bitcoin parlance) who hold onto huge amounts of currency. Those would've lost 99% of their fortune if they kept dollars in their mattress for a century. So what should they do instead? Invest that money to fuel the economy.
- mcguire 9y ago"And while it's not a perfect match, salaries now are definitely not what they were in 1920. A quick google gives the average salary in 1920 at $1236 although I can't seem to find a decent source for that." Interesting. This: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/20soirepar.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/20soirepar.pdf looks like a fascinating document with lots o' fun data. It gives $3269 for the 7million who filed income tax returns. A couple of inflation calculators at https://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_calculators/inflation_rate_calculator.asp https://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_calculators/in... give $41,000-42,000 for the inflation adjustment.
- pdkl95 9y ago> you wouldn't choose an inflationary currency. Inflation only hurts people that hold non-trivial amounts of that asset. Most people benefit from inflation as it makes their debts easier to pay. However, it's foolish to assume most people make make such choices rationally. People would choose currencies based on popularity and/or whatever they heard on TV. > I can't imagine anyone choosing the second option. "Signing transactions and having to authorize every transfer sounds like a lot of work. Bank $FOO will handle all that for me, for 'free' if I open a new account before $DATE." edit: Sure, the ability to use proper user-controlled, signed/authenticated transactions would be wonderful, regardless of the currency.
- mcguire 9y ago"Hayek points out that you wouldn't choose an inflationary currency. He relies on that to limit overall inflation. But you also don't have the deflationary problems of the gold standard, since it's possible to make more money at will if you need it." Ideally, you'd want your currency to expand (or contract, heaven forbid) at the same rate as the economy. But that's a little hard to do. A deflationary currency is way bad. (By definition, you're economically irrational if you spend it.) On the other hand, uncontrolled inflation is way bad, too. "Controlled" (in some, hopefully meaningful, sense of the word) inflationary currency is probably the best of the options.