3 ms·
No, that still goes to far. I'd accept "humans violate the rules in ways which are very occasionally, inadvertently safe."
by mikeash 9y ago
No, that still goes to far. I'd accept "humans violate the rules in ways which are very occasionally, inadvertently safe."
- emodendroket 9y agoOh, come on. Coming to a rolling stop at an empty, clearly visible intersection is not some sort of insane suicidal behavior.
- mikeash 9y agoI'm not saying it is. A rolling stop at a busy intersection where you barely miss other cars and/or pedestrians is insane behavior, though, and that's what I'm talking about. Yes, there are people who carefully evaluate the situation and only roll their stops when it's safe. They make up a minuscule percentage of the population, though. Most people just do it out of laziness or selfishness, and when they do it safely, it's a happy accident, not a deliberate policy.
- emodendroket 9y agoI disagree.
- naasking 9y ago> Coming to a rolling stop at an empty, clearly visible intersection is not some sort of insane suicidal behavior. The problem is that humans easily misjudge what they believe to be an empty, clearly visible intersection.
- emodendroket 9y agoIf you're the first person to the line you have the right of way anyway.
- devrelm 9y agoAs my driving instructor used to say, "Stop signs and red lights do not actually reach out and stop the other driver." The lesson: just because it's your turn to go does not mean that others will not enter the intersection when it's not their turn. I agree that rolling stops at a 4-way stop are generally safe when you can clearly see that no other cars are at or approaching the intersection. But in my experience, the fact that the other person is at fault has been little consolation for having to deal with a totaled car and a permanent backache.
- joejerryronnie 9y agoThe laws of physics always trump the laws of the road.
- emodendroket 9y agoOK, obviously that's true. But if it's empty, you have good visibility, and you plainly have the right of way, well, I'm just going to take it on faith that nobody is hurtling down the road at 80 mph. You can't possibly account for everything; that's the risk of driving.
- shkkmo 9y agoOr you could, stop, check the intersection and proceed safely like you are legally required to do.
- emodendroket 9y agoAnd that would foreclose the possibility of someone racing down the perpendicular street and ignoring the stop sign?
- diab0lic 9y agoNo, but it would increase the chance of you noticing that person and taking corrective action.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt's a matter of perspective. It looks a lot more insane when you're paid well enough to outsource those behaviors (and liability) to whoever's driving your Uber. It's like when a company makes a statement about supporting a living wage and contracts out its janitorial services who pay anything but.
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't understand what you're driving at.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt's easy to bitch about people not following the letter of the law when you're not spending 45min in a rush hour commute every day and the benefit of not following the letter of the law is not tangible to you.
- emodendroket 9y agoOh, I see. Yeah, I don't miss driving to work.
- mikeash 9y agoOn the contrary, I'm a lot more uptight about it when I drive frequently, because I eventually get tired of people nearly killing me or breaking my stuff because they can't be bothered to put the least bit of effort into their driving.
- jerf 9y agoYou notice the big violations. You do not even notice the small ones, which happen all the time. How many people cross solid lines? How many people sometimes drift a bit out of their lane? How many people scrupulously follow the speed limit like a computer does, not even accidentally drifting above it? How many people simply screw up the order of operations at a busy stop sign? How many people always scrupulously use their turn signals in accordance with the local laws? (You may use them frequently, even scrupulously, but I bet you often turn them on what is legally too late.) I've been driving through a construction zone all summer. People definitely don't drive "45 when workers are around". They don't slow down when the workers are behind the concrete barriers and a dozen feet from the road, and may drive 25 when they're sitting right next to the road with just a barrel a bit between you and them. Even a cop tailing you and desperately hunting for reasons to pull you over still probably lets through plenty of violations. There's too many laws for the cop to keep in their head.
- mikeash 9y agoCrossing solid lines is not illegal in my state. Drifting a bit out of your lane is pretty dangerous. Usually you get away with it, but if two people do it at the same time while adjacent, you're going to bump. Do it when there's oncoming traffic in the next lane (which I see all the damned time) then you could easily get people killed. Mildly exceeding the speed limit is fine, but people don't do it in a carefully considered way because they know it's still safe, they do it because they're in a hurry and know they probably won't get pulled over.
- Bartweiss 9y agoCrossing solid lines (or crossing a gore, at least) is illegal in my state. Meanwhile, a lot of highway on-ramps are painted with single-lane-width, high-angle merges that are dangerous to adhere to - they leave you making a ~30 degree turn while accelerating into traffic. As a result, everyone starts their merge early in the gore area, matches speed, and merges at a gentle angle. (The road designers presumably know this, and keep the marked path narrow regardless so that drivers won't attempt to form multiple lanes.) This is a pretty great example of what I'm describing - I don't think people make great decisions about violating driving rules, but I also don't think it's fair to call safe decisions "inadvertent". Not breaking that law is genuinely dangerous, and people violate it specifically to be safer.