3 ms·
And do the gravitational waves propagate at the speed of light?
by SideburnsOfDoom 9y ago
And do the gravitational waves propagate at the speed of light?
- perlgeek 9y agoYes
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoBasically, yes: The speed of both gravity waves and light waves is limited by c, the speed of light in vacuum. But actually, no, because the light is not in a vacuum - it's ricocheting out from the center of a star, and bouncing through the interstellar medium (which is incredibly sparse; very nearly a vacuum: but there's an awful lot of it between these events and us). This is also the mechanism behind neutrino detectors. When a star's core goes supernova, it releases a cataclysm of neutrinos which pass through the upper layers of the star almost unaffected. The light and radio waves are still bouncing around trying to get to the surface of the star, and the blast wave is still physically propagating much slower than the speed of light, but the neutrinos are long gone. That gives scientists a short time period to point their telescopes in the right direction! Further reading: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/235450/do-gravitational-waves-travel-faster-than-light https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/235450/do-gravit... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6253263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6253263
- jamiek88 9y agoYes and this is different in as much as LIGO / gravitational waves gave us the 'tip off' that the light was incoming, we fortunately had a satellite that captured that. It's a whole other information stream we are just learning how to use, basically with using gravitational waves we are at the stage Galileo was at with light. Very early, very low res but enough to give us massive new discoveries. So exciting.
- fpoling 9y agoFor 130 million light years the difference between gravitational wave signal and gamma burst is 2s. That constrains the speed difference to 1.6e-18 m/s. This is fascinating number especially given that speed of light is 3e8.
- alok-g 9y agoNewbie question: While this is a very small fractional difference, could it be theoretically significant? What is the explanation of this difference? My best guess is that this difference must also be there in when the waves _started_.
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoI'm not a physicist, but I did do the 101 course a long time ago. I read "That constrains the speed difference to 1.6e-18 m/s" as "we measured as accurately as we could, and if they do differ, they must differ by this amount or less, which could just be the tolerances of our experiment" In other words, there's always a confidence interval, the trick is to measure it and minimise it: The speeds could be identical numbers, but what was measured was an either no or a very small difference. Larger differences have been ruled out. Identical numbers are _suggested_.
- alok-g 9y agoWhat is observed is the delay between the two signals. Fractional speed difference is calculated from it. As I understand, there is little chance that the 2 second delta isn't real.
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoOK, but there are other possible explanations besides fundamental physics: either the order of events at the source, or the effects of the interstellar medium along the way.
- fpoling 9y ago