5 ms·
It is rather self-serving to say that people following the rules are creating danger. If you are driving in such a way that a dangerous (as opposed to merely in
by mannykannot 9y ago
It is rather self-serving to say that people following the rules are creating danger. If you are driving in such a way that a dangerous (as opposed to merely inconvenient) situation results from someone following the rules, you are not driving with sufficient caution.
- reacweb 9y agoFor example, to change lanes, a Parisian will put on his flashing light and change lanes just after even if a car is arriving. He knows that in Paris everyone is attentive to other cars and have seen his flasher. A non-Parisian guy's gonna put on his flasher and wait for space. This never happens and he ends up changing lanes very unexpectedly.
- yoz-y 9y agoSo... when there is somebody who isn't a Parisian and they hit a car because they did not know this, are they in fault? I live in Paris, and although I do not drive I have the impression that most drivers here are extremely inconsiderate. As an example, there is a crossing which is constantly congested with buses and lorries stuck in the middle here. This is mainly because nobody respects the rules or priorities. When an officer comes in to control the traffic instead of the lights, it gets "magically" cleaned up and the circulation is fluid.
- mannykannot 9y agoIf that driver is signaling, then a move should not be unexpected, especially if the unwritten rule is that one must force one's way into another lane. You are actually providing an example that the Parisian way of doing things is not as benignly efficient as you suggested in your first post.
- reacweb 9y agoIf you adopt the Parisian way, you can change lane very easily and quickly even if there is a big traffic jam. I have drive in traffic jam in smaller towns (like Cherbourg), it was more difficult to change lane. The fact that you can not change lane without forcing is a normal consequence of the increase of the traffic. I think the unwritten rule is that people should not turn on flashing lights too early before acting. The better communication of the intents and a fair level of trust that other drivers will understand it (and not try to block you) makes driving a lot easier (in Paris).
- mannykannot 9y ago> I think the unwritten rule is that people should not turn on flashing lights too early before acting. A bunch of highly nuanced rules like this seems very fragile. If you are driving in this manner, you have a responsibility to be alert for things breaking.
- stale2002 9y agoThe parisian way is resulting in a city with one of the highest traffic fatality rates in the world. The facts show that whatever the parisians are doing is definitely the wrong way to do it, and should be changed.
- KGIII 9y agoThe best way is, if someone signals a lane change, let them in.
- WalterSear 9y ago> He knows that in Paris everyone is attentive to other cars and have seen his flasher. 'We'll all just avoid making any mistakes' is a really unwise attitude anywhere, but particularly when driving a car.
- dclowd9901 9y agoThis is silly. You're ignoring a reality where a culture has _figured out on their own_ an optimal way to navigate from point A to B in bad traffic, (mostly) safely while constraining themselves to the _intent_ of the law, if not the letter. There's no better realization of distributed peace. Who is the self-serving person who thinks they are entitled to travel to Paris and drive around without understanding the cultural norms of their unspoken driving rules?
- naasking 9y ago> You're ignoring a reality where a culture has _figured out on their own_ an optimal way to navigate from point A to B in bad traffic, (mostly) safely while constraining themselves to the _intent_ of the law, if not the letter. Is it a reality? Sounds like conjecture to me, and the fact that many humans are killed in traffic fatalities certainly suggests otherwise.
- mst 9y agoDriving at roughly the same speed as the rest of traffic is definitely much safer than driving the posted speed limit. Any other such commonly observed violation would probably have to be studied to answer the question - and given humans' tendencies to take on a fairly uniform level of risk no matter what the rules are, I suspect the question may need to be "does this keep the risk level constants while increasing throughput" rather than "does this reduce risk". So ... it's plausible both ways so far as I can tell.
- tertius 9y ago> Driving at roughly the same speed as the rest of traffic is definitely much safer than driving the posted speed limit. Who is causing the danger of driving the maximum legal speed. Also, it's rare that all of the traffic flow is above the maximum legal speed. The ones speeding then cause the differential, which is the danger. The fault is not with those not keeping up. But rather with those breaking the law because it's convenient.
- subhobroto 9y ago> It is rather self-serving to say that people following the rules are creating danger Not so simple. The rules are created via legislation affected by lobbying. The AAA for decades have been lobbying to keep speed limits low. In the perfect world, speed limits would be informed by the 85% percentile speed of engineering surveys. In reality, it's much different. If a large number of drivers are driving at a speed higher than a prima facie speed limit, the speed limit could actually be low, in which case, the drivers actually following the prima facie speed limit are creating a hazard to the flow of traffic.
- dragonwriter 9y agoOTOH, if the prima facie limit were followed consistently (or enforced effectively), people would not be exceeding it, and speeds would be more tightly clustered and safer.