3 ms·
I'm sure there are some drivers affected by peer pressure but I would be surprised if it's a significant figure as there are already a significant number of dri
by hnlmorg 9y ago
I'm sure there are some drivers affected by peer pressure but I would be surprised if it's a significant figure as there are already a significant number of drivers who do stick to the speed limits. You tend to see worse driving in areas where people feel safe (ie places they drive frequently) or when they are themselves in a hurry (eg "rush hour") but those are more personal to the individual rather than pressures placed on them by other drivers.
Furthermore, I'd agree that increasing the limits above what humans currently already do would be a bad idea. At least as long as it is still legal to have human operated vehicles on the roads. However the issue we are discussing is whether you want AI to emulate some of the more impatient behaviours of humans. In many instances I think it would be safe. So it seems logical to bring AI up to our level of throughput.
Eventually the long term goal of driverless cars is reduced congestion due to the improved throughput provided by AI. But so long as there are humans also driving cars on the road the only way AI could improve throughput is to emulate human behaviour to some extent (ie not the worst of human behaviour but more our ability to judge when we need to navigate tighter spaces in congested junctions - for example).
- TeMPOraL 9y agoMy point is that: - Assume that drivers who engage in the "more impatient behaviours" are increasing the amount of accidents compared to what would happen if they stick to the rules. - Note that introduction of self-driving cars is a perfect opportunity to use them as a forcing function on the road, to make those impatient drivers stick to the rules. - If both of the above is true, we can save more lives right now by having the self-driving cars stick to the rules than by having them emulate the impatient drivers - a task which the machines will handle fine, but which would keep such behaviour legitimized for humans. Now I'm least sure about the first assumption; it intuitively seems true, but beyond occasional articles pointing out speeding and careless driving as primary sources of traffic accidents, I haven't spend time evaluating the data on that. The second point seems intuitively true from experience of how drivers adapt to other drivers around them. Self-driving cars can be made stubborn by default, so everyone else would have no choice but to adapt to them.
- hnlmorg 9y agoI understand your point but I don't agree with your conclusion. You cannot assume that human drivers will drive any more differently when there are AI cars on the road sticking to the limit than they already currently do with non-AI cars on the road sticking to the limit. Either way they're still going to want to drive impatiently. Take learner drivers for example, people sometimes drive worse around them (pulling out in front of them etc) because they simply don't want to get caught behind them. This is even before they've sampled the competency of the learner. The L plate is often enough to make bad drives drive worse. Thus the only definite way you can argue that AI would slow down bad drivers would be if the bad drivers were the ones being driven by the AI. In which case we are back to the point about whether AI can safely drive a little more aggressively (for want a better description) due to it's greater competency at driving.