3 ms·
While that is a fair point I think a reasonable counterargument would be that the current rules are based around the fallibility of humans (stopping distance, s
by hnlmorg 9y ago
While that is a fair point I think a reasonable counterargument would be that the current rules are based around the fallibility of humans (stopping distance, speed limits, etc) which is less applicable to AI due to it's lower reaction times and greater awareness of the environment around it (in terms of it's constant sensor sampling when humans would normally "zone out").
- Piskvorrr 9y agoMost of the rules are based on physics. The stopping distance increases quadratically with speed, whether the driver is a human or not.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoUp until human drivers get removed from the public roads entirely, we need to apply human-centric rules, because humans are the weakest link in the chain. One of the problem with human drivers is that they feel they know better, and routinely disrespect the rules. Peer pressure makes it hard for individual drivers to follow the law when so many people get angry at them for that. Introduction of self-driving cars provides us with good opportunity to improve the safety of human traffic - autonomous cars don't care if you're angry at them, and by following the rules, they can force everyone else to do the same. That is, unless we chose to have self-driving cars ignore the rules too, like the article suggests.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoDrivers are at least protected by their metal shell. What of the bikers, cyclists, and pedestrians? Those are unlikely to become non-self-driving, so to speak.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoTrue. For that reason, I doubt self-driving cars will be going 200km/h through the city centre. I can imagine autonomous motorcycles. The hardware doesn't take that much extra space to make it infeasible. Whether anyone would like to use such a vehicle is another matter :).
- Piskvorrr 9y agoI can imagine flying cars, and have been promised them for a century now. (As for autonomous motorcycles, I don't see a use-case)
- hnlmorg 9y agoI'm sure there are some drivers affected by peer pressure but I would be surprised if it's a significant figure as there are already a significant number of drivers who do stick to the speed limits. You tend to see worse driving in areas where people feel safe (ie places they drive frequently) or when they are themselves in a hurry (eg "rush hour") but those are more personal to the individual rather than pressures placed on them by other drivers. Furthermore, I'd agree that increasing the limits above what humans currently already do would be a bad idea. At least as long as it is still legal to have human operated vehicles on the roads. However the issue we are discussing is whether you want AI to emulate some of the more impatient behaviours of humans. In many instances I think it would be safe. So it seems logical to bring AI up to our level of throughput. Eventually the long term goal of driverless cars is reduced congestion due to the improved throughput provided by AI. But so long as there are humans also driving cars on the road the only way AI could improve throughput is to emulate human behaviour to some extent (ie not the worst of human behaviour but more our ability to judge when we need to navigate tighter spaces in congested junctions - for example).