3 ms·
Put it like this: I live in Australia, and banning guns worked really well. I cannot express how little that "individual autonomy" argument resonates with me.
by nl 9y ago
Put it like this: I live in Australia, and banning guns worked really well. I cannot express how little that "individual autonomy" argument resonates with me.
- mindslight 9y agoWe're arguing about the equivalence I drew, right? Are you just talking about guns, or does the individual autonomy argument not resonate with you regarding encryption as well? If so, then which philosophical arguments (regarding encryption) do resonate with you?
- nl 9y agoThat encryption protects my right to communicate privately. Backdoors cannot be implemented securely, so they cannot be accepted.
- mindslight 9y agoIsn't this the same thing as "individual autonomy" ? Are you just drawing a quantitative distinction that the damage caused by societal guns is too much, while the damage caused by societal encryption (in the inevitable "ticking clock" scenario) is not?
- nl 9y agoNo. Speech is not a weapon. Even planning a crime is not harmful in itself.
- mindslight 9y agoI've made a similar argument myself plenty of times. But one implication is that, in the context of an assassination market, a buyer isn't committing (a crime, violence, harm, etc).
- nl 9y agoNo it's not. It's trivial to outlaw specific things. In fact that is already done. The speech isn't the crime, it's the involvement in the planning of crime which is a crime.
- mindslight 9y ago> Even planning a crime is not harmful in itself ... > the involvement in the planning of crime which is a crime. Since we're talking about what should be a crime, then your two statements here seem to contradict one another. For an argument to be consistent you can choose either framework, but can't switch between the two. If you want to say the difference between speech and a gun is that speech is not a weapon (in the context of encryption), then you've got to also accept that buyers in an assassination market are merely speaking, and it is whomever goes out and commits the physical act that bears the full blame. Conversely, if you want to say that all participants in an assassination market are conspiring to commit a crime, then you've got to admit there are times where it would serve the public good to be able to prosecute that crime. This brings the distinction between encryption and guns down to the amount of expected harm versus benefits - but still the same tension where some amount of individual autonomy is given up for some amount of societal protection. But maybe I'm missing something.
- nl 9y agoSomething that isn't harmful yet can and should be a crime. Pretty simple. Planning assassination should be a crime. Using encryption shouldn't be.
- mindslight 9y ago(Drawing that distinction feels like unnecessarily adding another dimension to the conversation, but okay) If planning an assassination is a crime, does it follow that the state/society has an interest in preventing and/or interrupting an in-progress instance of that crime?
- mythrwy 9y agoOwning a gun is not harmful in and of itself either. OP has an interesting point.
- rjeli 9y agoTerrorists kill lots of people. Terrorists can use encryption to hide from the government, and so can a tyrannized population use it to organize and resist. Things shouldn’t be banned because they kill people. Often, we sacrifice safety for the ability to resist tyranny.
- eadmund 9y agoNo doubt banning encryption might also work well (e.g. with government-mandated scanners running on every legal OS) at preventing criminals from using unbreakable encryption. I think you & I both agree that banning encryption is still not worth it.