4 ms·
Why are you so sure that people are being duped? What if the present state of affairs is actually desirable by the majority of the populace, if they had a prope
by jcranmer 9y ago
Why are you so sure that people are being duped? What if the present state of affairs is actually desirable by the majority of the populace, if they had a proper understanding?
Put more simply, how are you sure of the rightness of your cause? How would you find out what is wrong, what objective measure could you choose? If your tactics don't work, would you admit defeat--or would you double down on your message, put stronger rhetorical flourishes on it, accentuate the dystopia/utopia dichotomy you propose? Would you still criticize your enemies for propaganda while you espouse your own, arguing it's not propaganda because it's correct?
The great thing about democracy is that it provides a fairly objective definition of what is "correct." The bad thing about democracy is that a lot of people, particularly smart people, absolutely hate it when they're wrong.
- mindslight 9y agoI never said that people were being duped. The majority earnestly believes in centralized control by the majority! There is no singular "wake up" moment or message - it's democracy all the way down. My comment isn't populist, but individualist. > The great thing about democracy is that it provides a fairly objective definition of what is "correct." You've got some hills to climb. Good luck.
- leereeves 9y ago> The great thing about democracy is that it provides a fairly objective definition of what is "correct." Democracy reveals what's popular and makes the popular powerful. I think history shows clearly that "popular" is not the same as "correct".
- ENOTTY 9y agoI think using democracy to determine "objective" correctness is not necessary to play the devil's advocate. To put it simply, if a democratic society decides that it doesn't want unbreakable encryption and that it wants all encryption subject to 4th Amendment procedures, why should that desire be overridden? That's actually why I find EFF's point about CALEA rather convincing.
- mindslight 9y ago> if a democratic society decides that it doesn't want unbreakable encryption and that it wants all encryption subject to 4th Amendment procedures, why should that desire be overridden? The general concept of a right, outside of what $ruler declares. If a monarchy doesn't want unbreakable encryption, why should that desire be overridden? The only thing that differs is the process by which centralized decisions are reached. You might have total faith in one of those decision processes, but I don't.
- ENOTTY 9y agoNot sure there have ever been absolute rights in the United States. So that means rights have to be weighed against certain circumstances. If the democratic society decides against your conception of the proper weighing of rights, you have the right to continue to try to convince your peers while complying with the law, or to leave.
- qball 9y ago>If the democratic society decides against your conception of the proper weighing of rights, you have the right to continue to try to convince your peers while complying with the law Society is always right, by definition. When your democratic society decides it's OK to kill all of Subgroup X, I guess that's totally fine morally and ethically (and if you're a member of Subgroup X, it's unethical to defend yourself). After all, the majority has investigated itself and found that it has done nothing wrong.
- ENOTTY 9y agoYep! As a minority, you better hope that (or can convince) the majority values the rights that you use most often (life, due process, etc) over what the majority sees as the gain from depriving you of your rights. This is fundamentally authoritarian, I acknowledge. But it's reality and believing it's the opposite doesn't do anyone any good.