4 ms·
Are you deliberately trying to alienate half your readers or are you completely unaware? Great way to pull this discussion off track in the second comment. It'
by nl 9y ago
Are you deliberately trying to alienate half your readers or are you completely unaware?
Great way to pull this discussion off track in the second comment. It's almost like you are trying to divide opponents of back doors.
- mindslight 9y agoI wasn't deliberately trying, but good point. Do you have a better example? Encryption and guns have been long associated, as they're both tools that give individuals power. Power that can inherently be wielded to do harm. Mash this up with references to scary "other" people, and we get the inevitable "only criminals" narrative. As I allude to in the second comment, I'm not really interested in guns. Despite our hyperpolarized society, I neither see the reason to personally own one nor tell other people they cannot.
- nl 9y agoAnd there you go again, trying to justify something I disagree with so completely and utterly that it's difficult to avoid an argument.
- mindslight 9y agoI don't really know how to respond. Obviously it's a good idea to avoid fall into the "gun rights debate" based on how tired and unproductive it is. You've avoided this twice, so good job (I mean this earnestly). On the other hand, the parallels are quite strong. Despite the best hopes of the wider tech community, I don't see the "backdoors create insecurity" argument having a solid basis or political merit. So we're left with a similar debate about individual autonomy, and the ability of "lone wolves" to operate with im-pre-punity. Perhaps try your gun stance on regarding encryption? I'd detail a straightforward example, but such things are inherently bombshells because we hypothesize in extremes. The media will certainly push the same "ticking clock" scenarios when needed.
- nl 9y agoPut it like this: I live in Australia, and banning guns worked really well. I cannot express how little that "individual autonomy" argument resonates with me.
- mindslight 9y agoWe're arguing about the equivalence I drew, right? Are you just talking about guns, or does the individual autonomy argument not resonate with you regarding encryption as well? If so, then which philosophical arguments (regarding encryption) do resonate with you?
- nl 9y agoThat encryption protects my right to communicate privately. Backdoors cannot be implemented securely, so they cannot be accepted.
- mindslight 9y agoIsn't this the same thing as "individual autonomy" ? Are you just drawing a quantitative distinction that the damage caused by societal guns is too much, while the damage caused by societal encryption (in the inevitable "ticking clock" scenario) is not?
- nl 9y agoNo. Speech is not a weapon. Even planning a crime is not harmful in itself.
- mindslight 9y agoI've made a similar argument myself plenty of times. But one implication is that, in the context of an assassination market, a buyer isn't committing (a crime, violence, harm, etc).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]