3 ms·
Conversely, every nutjob with a gun argues against basic supply and demand analysis, saying that restricting the supply of weapons that simplify killing won't r
by lern_too_spel 9y ago
Conversely, every nutjob with a gun argues against basic supply and demand analysis, saying that restricting the supply of weapons that simplify killing won't reduce the number of killings, when everybody who has gone through Econ 101 knows that shifting the supply curve to the right will result in a new, lower equilibrium number of killings.
If you care so much about freedom, why aren't you arguing that Walmart should be allowed to sell ready-made phone-triggered bombs to anybody who wants one?
The EFF makes a good case for why Rosenstein is wrong, and it's not some black and white freedom issue.
- mindslight 9y agoFirstly, because I'm not in the market for phone-triggered bombs, especially at the scale/price of wanting mass-produced ones. More importantly because, as I alluded to above, I don't personally believe that small arms are effective at preventing tyranny (in fact, they seem to foster of a false sense of security!). So while I wouldn't be against such a proposal, I believe my focus is better spent on communications freedom. Also, even if we brush past the oddity of analyzing recreational murder in supply-demand terms - wouldn't it be more straightforward to decrease the demand (eg indict the news media for profiting off of it) rather than increasing the difficulty of a single method?
- lern_too_spel 9y ago> Firstly, because I'm not in the market for phone-triggered bombs, especially at the scale/price of wanting mass-produced ones. So you're only interested in the freedom to do what you want, not what other people want? Then since I'm not in the market for guns, I should be allowed to restrict you from getting one too. > Also, even if we brush past the oddity of analyzing recreational murder in supply-demand terms.... Markets aren't "odd." They simply exist. You can design markets to further society's interests, or you can pretend that we live in a pre-enlightenment era where we don't know how anything works and don't care to figure anything out.
- mindslight 9y ago> So you're only interested in the freedom to do what you want Well yes, this is kind of how interest works. Not being interested in something does not imply being interested in banning it! This binary fallacy is at the root of today's politics. > Markets aren't "odd." They simply exist Sure, but you'd have to do a lot more defining to flesh out how you're actually applying the market paradigm. You seem to indicate that ability to kill is "supply". But is the demand a primal desire to kill, stochastic mental process, attention seeking, call of Evil, or what? Will changing the blade in my utility knife increase the likelihood that I'll attack someone with it? More often than not, the justification of "economics" is trotted out to obscure a blatant political point.
- lern_too_spel 9y ago> Not being interested in something does not imply being interested in banning it! To put it more concretely, this means you would want people to be able to buy ready-made phone-triggered bombs of arbitrary size at Wal-Mart. > You seem to indicate that ability to kill is "supply". I already explained that access to weapons that simplify killing is the supply. > More often than not, the justification of "economics" is trotted out to obscure a blatant political point. In my experience, more often than not, people who don't understand supply and demand simply don't understand economics.
- mindslight 9y agoYou still didn't answer if changing the blade in my utility knife will increase the likelihood that I'll attack someone.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoChanging the blade in your utility knife will change the likelihood that you will kill somebody if the blade is more effective at killing. P(kill somebody with knife) = P(attack somebody with knife) * P(kill somebody with knife | attack somebody with knife). This is from chapter 1 of a Statistics 101 textbook. Why are you so opposed to thinking rationally that you point out silly arguments that I neglected to dignify with an answer?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Conversely, every nutjob with a gun argues against basic supply and demand analysis, saying that restricting the supply of weapons that simplify killing won't reduce the number of killings, when everybody who has gone through Econ 101 knows that shifting the supply curve to the right will result in a new, lower equilibrium number of killings. Econ 101 also says that if you restrict the supply of guns but not knives or rocks or IEDs, substitution will occur. So the real question is how much the curve shifts. And we need the real number, not politically convenient fictions like calculating the change in the number of crimes committed using the prohibited weapons without counting crimes committed using substitute weapons. Or claiming credit for a reduction in crime that only tracks the rate that violent crime has been declining world-wide for decades independent of any single policy. It's not necessarily the case that the result is even in the right direction because of the deterrent effect. It's possible that criminals are deterred by the prospect of being shot by a victim and if you make guns less available then overall violence increases due to the loss of the deterrent. This is clearly a situation where you need to look at the evidence, except that it's a political issue and each side has their own set of numbers.
- lern_too_spel 9y ago> So the real question is how much the curve shifts. And we need the real number, not politically convenient fictions like calculating the change in the number of crimes committed using the prohibited weapons without counting crimes committed using substitute weapons. We already have several empirical studies that show that there is no perfect substitution and that the new equilibrium is significantly lower.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> except that it's a political issue and each side has their own set of numbers.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoWhere are these numbers that go against common sense? Look at my bombs example, which shows the absurdity of that argument even to people who have grown up in a gun culture.