5 ms·
It’s funny. I’ve heard the “Disagree but commit” from a lot of managers lately; usually used to shut peons up. Ironic that it’s original usage (at least where t
by falcolas 9y ago
It’s funny. I’ve heard the “Disagree but commit” from a lot of managers lately; usually used to shut peons up. Ironic that it’s original usage (at least where these managers heard it from) speaks to the opposite direction: leadership should trust their teams.
- brad0 9y agoI thought it was more along the lines of “if you’re in the minority and you aren’t convincing people then don’t invest energy into it and go with the flow”.
- falcolas 9y agoIt’s that too; the advantage of a 3 word maxim: it means what you want it to mean. My managers want the peons to follow the directions from on high. Bezos wanted to trust the people he hired to do the right thing, even if he disagreed. I, an employee, tend to go with your interpretation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brad0 9y agoYou’re right, I like your breakdown of the issue. The “mantra” should be a reminder of the cultural value. ie: you learn the value by seeing it in interactions between people first. The mantra then orients you toward the cultural value. Instead some people are taking the mantra and twisting it to create a culture that is useful to them. Haha, it kind of reminds me of religion. :S
- daveFNbuck 9y agoWhen leadership trusts their teams, they're trusting the manager. Combining these uses means that the manager has support from above and below to execute their projects.
- whipoodle 9y agoUgh, that phrase is so grim. I kinda wish people in this industry would just tell each other to “shut up and deal with it” if that’s what they effectively mean.
- baus 9y agoWhat I thought was interesting, while I haven't read the shareholder's letters, is that the OP says Bezos applies this to himself when evaluating ideas from his own teams
- zenlikethat 9y agoHe does. He specifically mentions at least one example where he didn't want to do something (I think make a new TV show) but everyone on the team thought it was a good idea so he committed to it despite not agreeing it was a good idea.
- mabbo 9y agoEven internally to Amazon, it's misunderstood. The point is to gather all the facts, make a decision as a team or group, then have everyone commit to the decision and not whine about how they should have done what I said we should do. You disagree, but you commit to the decision of the group for cohesion and productivity. It's also a means to prevent groupthink. No one should be thought poorly of for disagreeing, so everyone should be giving all their thoughts, even ones that contradict what the group is thinking. Just so long as they get those points out before the decision is made, of course.
- kevan 9y agoExactly. No matter how good an idea is, if people in the team are sabotaging it because they don't like it you'll have a bad time. A variation on Patton's quote: A mediocre plan executed well is better than a great plan executed poorly.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoThat particular phrasing may be specific to Amazon, but I've heard the same concept used in other management training classes. "If you agree 80%, then commit 100%" was another way I've heard it said.