9 ms·
A “negative emissions” plant has opened in Iceland
- exabrial 9y agoI think calling it a 'plant' may be deceptive. The picture makes it look like a package the size of a dumpster, not quite the size of a shipping container. Is the byproduct (not sure if it's purified gas or a solid compound) of any industrial or material use?
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Is the byproduct (not sure if it's purified gas or a solid compound) of any industrial or material use? No. The byproduct is injected back into the ground to be remineralized, hopefully locked up to prevent its re-release into the atmosphere. EDIT: If you used the byproduct in another process where it eventually would make its way back into the atmosphere, the process would no longer be carbon negative. "This month, Climeworks installed a unit that captures carbon dioxide directly from the air and transfers it to CarbFix to inject underground. Because CarbFix has been monitoring the injection sites for the last three years, they can be sure there will be no leakage. And once mineralized, the CO2 will remain trapped for thousands or millions of years. This makes the Climeworks-CarbFix system the world’s first verified “negative emissions” plant."
- exabrial 9y agoBummer. Too bad the 'mineral' couldn't be used to make bricks or something.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI have seen some efforts at carbon negative cement; that might be an input that could accept this buuuuuut its most likely not as efficient as shoving the CO2 down into the ground with high speed pumps. http://berc.berkeley.edu/carbon-negative-cement-turning-climate-liability-asset/ http://berc.berkeley.edu/carbon-negative-cement-turning-clim...
- dogma1138 9y agoI don’t really understand the article cemenet manufacturing releases CO2 because the limestone (CaCO3) is calcinated and turned into lime (CaO) in the process of making cement. The article says (2nd half the first half just describes a cemenet that isn’t made with limestone) that they capture the CO2 and make more limestone form it I’m guessing by sequestering it lime so in theory it can be carbon neutral (albeit I don’t know where they get the lime from without breaking limestone) but how does it become carbon negative?
- dogma1138 9y agoYou can sequester the carbon in a product and still be able to use it without releasing it to the atmosphere. For example you can sequester the CO2 in limestone which is a useful building material.
- jaggederest 9y agoLimestone (calcium carbonate) is even easy to make. You can make it "at home" by dissolving unslaked lime (calcium oxide) in water and blowing bubbles in it with a straw. The real problem is that calcium oxide is usually converted from limestone via massive calcining, which releases... CO2.
- rrobukef 9y agoI question the wisdom of tapping another finite resource to battle long-term climate change.
- perpetualcrayon 9y agoI'm not that familiar with this sort of thing, but my thinking has always been that: If we could theoretically terraform some other planet, why can't similar things be done on earth to improve our atmosphere? Especially now w/ renewable energy at historically low prices. My fear is that once this kind of technology is deployed at scale, it could make industry far too complacent again.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rosser 9y agoIt's not that we can't "terraform" our own planet. It's that the consequences of getting it wrong, in doing so deliberately, could easily be worse than those of the "accidental" ways we've been doing it for a couple centuries now...
- ekianjo 9y ago> theoretically terraform some other planet That's the problem, it's all just theory and even for Mars we don't think it would be easy. For planets like Venus, straight impossible at our current level of tech and the constraints of such worlds.
- wallace_f 9y ago>Mars, not easy; Venus, impossible Mars may very well be much easier, but the bias towards Mars may also be largely cultural: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gJ5KV3rzuag https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gJ5KV3rzuag
- eru 9y agoYes, we can 'terraform' earth. The problem is cost.
- nielsbjerg 9y agoOne could even go as far as to say, that we're successful in doing just that. Only in the opposite direction of what we've discovered to be necessary.
- orthoganol 9y agoOut of curiosity, we would need ~500 of these stations in their current form to offset a typical coal power plant (7.5 thousand tons co2/ year, a claim from Climework's about video, v. 3.5 million tons co2 / year), or about 5-6 million stations to offset global co2 yearly emission (40-45 billion tons co2/ year).
- wereHamster 9y ago...at the current efficiency levels. Note that this is only their second installation, so don't expect any miracles. The technology will improve, I'm sure.
- gandreani 9y agoWow really? That seems like a small number. Given that aroun 70+ million cars were sold in 2016, we probably have the industrial capacity to offset the yearly emissions. I wonder how cheap these will get and if they can be deployed en masse easily
- lucisferre 9y agoThey also mention that it is considerably more efficient to capture carbon at the source. The CO2 concentration is about 200 times higher at the plant (10% vs 0.04%). They state that it costs about 1/10 as much to capture at the source. So extrapolating from that, then the the plant they built in Switzerland, which 900 tonnes/yr directly from the air, could potentially capture 9000 tonnes/yr and would handily manage a coal power plant. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/switzerland-giant-new-machine-sucking-carbon-directly-air http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/switzerland-giant-new...
- ISL 9y agoMost plants have negative carbon-dioxide emissions. The trick is not cutting them down.
- bitL 9y agoThe more CO2 is in atmosphere, the sweeter and less mineral-rich plants become, becoming less beneficial to poisonous to surrounding animals and insects.
- kbutler 9y agoDo you have a source for "poisonous"? The studies I've seen indicate that some grain crops may lose a bit of nutrient density (zinc, iron decreasing by 5-14%) while other crops are unaffected or may increase in nutrition. e.g., overview at https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/swelling-co2-cuts-nutrition-in-food/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/swelling-co2-cuts...
- eternauta3k 9y agoThe trick is to cut them down at the optimal point (some time before they stop growing) and replant. Then use the wood in a way which won't release the carbon back into the atmosphere: don't burn it or let it rot.
- londons_explore 9y agoStopping wood rotting for 20 years is doable. Stopping wood rotting for 1000 years is rather tricky. If you let the wood rot or burn, you're back to where you started.
- nnethercote 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar
- hydrogen18 9y agoSink it all to the bottom of a cold freshwater lake?
- abalone 9y agoNot to pour too much cold water on this, but aside from the extreme cost -- let's just assume that comes down -- these plants ideally need to be located near specific basalt geological formations and need a substantial freshwater supply (27:1 ratio to captured CO2). So while it is most economical to capture at source power plants it may not be geographically possible. And when they're not located by a source it's 10X less efficient.
- alexandercrohde 9y agoOf course. The article doesn't mean nor need to imply that this technology is practical yet, simply to illustrate progress is being made (and it is). For any technology you can poo-poo the early stages ("This Wright brothers plane can only fly 200 feet," "This computer is the size of a room and costs several years' salary").
- pedrocr 9y ago>"Moreover, they’ve been able to do it for less than $30 per metric ton of CO2." If my math is right this means that with ~5% of the cost of the fuel you could offset car emissions to make transportation carbon neutral. Seems quite cheap if that's the case.
- GigabyteCoin 9y agoThat was achieved by placing the scrubber directly on the coal plant's exhaust stack.
- pedrocr 9y agoThis particular solution doesn't scale (most power isn't geothermal and we should just offline coal entirely) but the fact that we're already in the ballpark is at least promising.
- jgamman 9y agobut it does create options for a lot of countries lucky enough to have geothermal resources ie, those around the pacific rim, NE africa, east coast US and Italy. not a lot of driver for domestic electricity production but carbon capture is a world-wide market...
- EADGBE 9y agoOh great, now people will start refuting the need for trees.