5 ms·
> Jeremy won international fame for a mutation that caused his shell to coil left instead of right. For years, people searched for another lefty snail with whic
by gus_massa 9y ago
> Jeremy won international fame for a mutation that caused his shell to coil left instead of right. For years, people searched for another lefty snail with which he could mate. Shortly before his death, she was found.
Since most of the snails (all?) are hermaphrodites isn't this use of "he" and "she" wrong? (or at least misleading?)
> All of the babies were born with a right-handed shell. This means the gene causing a snail’s directional twist (and body asymmetry in other animals), described last year in Current Biology, could take more than a generation for its recessive form to appear.
This doesn't make any sense. Is the left handled shell caused by a recessive gene? If this were the case, the offspring of two left handled snails should be also left handled. Is it possible that this was not caused by a genetic mutation, and it's just that a tiny amount of normal snails get the wrong orientation?
- KGIII 9y ago> the wrong direction? Sure, flaunting your snail privilege! /s But, seriously, maybe it starts off really small and is a conservation of angular momentum thing, sort of like how most solar bodies orbit counterclockwise? Only really small and, well, probably pretty slow. Something like a small grain of sand could maybe make it spin the other way? Do keep in mind that I'm a mathematician. I haven't actually taken a bio course since about 1983.
- avip 9y ago>maybe it starts off really small and is a conservation of angular momentum thing Being a mathematician does not imply you can get away with saying something that makes so little sense :)
- KGIII 9y agoPfft... Does too! I seriously wonder if it's something like a lump of skin or dirt that makes it go the opposite direction, or the direction of least resistance. Y'all busy looking at genes and stuff. I am gonna stick with simple. It should be noted that my last bio course was well before the human genome was sequenced. I doubt they'd even done snails. Yeah, I'm sticking with that. It's either that or aliens.
- gus_massa 9y ago>>> conservation of angular momentum thing For the snails, probably you mean something like "initial break of symmetry". In the initial steps of the embryo, it must define the front-back, top-down, right-left axis. (I'm not sure about the technical names.) IIRC, each one is defined by some gradient of chemical signal, they are not mechanical, but I'm not sure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morphogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morphogenesis Anyway, it would be a nice experiment to twist a snail embryo and see the development. In particular, the snail of the article has the reproductive and internal organs in the opposite side of most snails. What happens when you twist a snail embryo, do the internal organs get the mirrored position too??? Somewhat related: This explains some parts of the front-back axis "Evo-Devo (Despacito Biology Parody) | A Capella Science" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydqReeTV_vk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydqReeTV_vk
- jccalhoun 9y agothat might explain the shell but the article also says that the snails organs are also reversed so it couldn't mate with righty snails.
- leggomylibro 9y agoCould be multiple genes. One snail has L1/L1 and L2/R2 for a right-handed shell, one has R1/L1 and L2/L2 for a right-handed shell, and one of their children has L1/L1 and L2/L2 for a LEFT-HANDER!!! Just as an example. It definitely does not work exactly like that, which is about as much as I'm confident in saying on the subject.
- gus_massa 9y agoThe article in Current Biology is about a single gene. In your example the R1 and R2 genes are dominant, and L1 and L2 are recessive. In you model, if two left-handed snail mate, all the offspring will be left-handed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GavinMcG 9y agoThat's the understanding we'd get from a high school biology course, but it's not that simple.
- avip 9y ago[explain by example] Anemone colours table D => Dominant R => Recesive * => does not matter | Red | White | Purple | Result | | RR | * | * | RED | | D* | RR | * | WHITE | | D* | D* | RR | PURPLE | | D* | D* | D* | PINKISH | It's just as if everything they've taught us @school was wrong!
- gus_massa 9y agoYour table is wrong. When there is a dominant and a recessive allele, in the simple case you see only the effect of the dominant one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dominance_(genetics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dominance_(genetics) I'll try to fix your table, but I prefer to use white as the "default" color. I'm not sure about anemones. One possibility is that the color depend only of one gene that has three variants (alleles). * White (recessive): "w" * Red (dominant): "R" * Purple (dominant): "P" The table is: | Genes | Result | | ww | WHITE | | wR or RR | RED | | wP or PP | PURPLE | | RP | PINKISH | Other possibility is that there are two genes that produce the color. Each one has a dominant variant that produce the color and a recessive variant without effect. * White: default color, no gene for this * Red: "Y"es (dominant) -or- "n"o (recesive) * Purple: "Y"es (dominant) -or- "n"o (recesive) The table is: | Red | Purple | Result | | nn | nn | WHITE | | nY or YY | nn | RED | | nn | nY or YY | PURPLE | | nY or YY | nY or YY | PINKISH | Another possibility is the opposite case, that there are two genes that produce the color. Each one has a recessive variant that produce the color and a dominant variant without effect. * White: default color, no gene for this * Red: "y"es (recessive) or "N"o (dominant) * Purple: "y"es (recessive) or "N"o (dominant) The table is: | Red | Purple | Result | | yN or NN | yN or NN | WHITE | | yy | yN or NN | RED | | yN or NN | yy | PURPLE | | yy | yy | PINKISH | Or there can be one gene that has a dominant allele that produce color and other gene that has a recessive gen that produce color. Or two genes with three alleles, or more genes, or more alleles, or ... But in any of these cases, the sentence in the article makes any sense.
- phyzome 9y agoIt could also be that it's not a simple dominance trait, or even that you need n different locations to be heterozygous or something like that. In any event, the fact that there was a cluster of them on a farm means there's a good chance there's a genetic component.
- yellowapple 9y agoAn environmental component in that farm seems just as likely an explanation for "a bunch of snails from the same place have the same mutation".