4 ms·
I think this has less to do about signal to noise and more to do with crowd control. BFR as a project is out of touch with the current affairs at Tesla and Spa
by dogma1138 9y ago
I think this has less to do about signal to noise and more to do with crowd control.
BFR as a project is out of touch with the current affairs at Tesla and SpaceX which means that there is basically no negative sentiment that can be generated from asking questions about the topic or their answers.
A general AMA however will likely touch about things like the failure to support Autopilot 2.0 hardware on schedule, Model 3 delivery delays, Falcon Heavy delays, and those are just the light stuff.
One does have to wonder why is there an AMA on the only detached and "universally rosie" subject just as Tesla announced layoffs.
While I don't think it was planned, I do have a strong suspicion that the AMA was intentionally focused and the mods were asked to enforce question rules (and looks like more strictly than usual even based on previous Musk AMAs).
- ProblemFactory 9y ago> AMA was intentionally focused and the mods were asked to enforce question rules I don't think the mods had to be even asked to do it. The AMA was posted in /r/space, and widely advertised in /r/spacex. There was a group effort to get technical BFR questions upvoted from /r/spacex members. I would guess that even without any outside influence, the mods and most voters did not care about Tesla questions - Tesla only matters to the extent of "does it help finance Mars plans" for them.
- greglindahl 9y agoTesla is the #1 automobile brand in owner satisfaction and you think it's important to ask Elon about Autopilot 2.0 software being late in an AMA, which has a limited number of questions. Gotcha. Even if the AMA was about Tesla, that probably wouldn't make the list.
- mikeash 9y agoHow does it make the slightest bit of sense that an AMA on a space forum would be intended as a deflection from firings at a totally different company in a different field? A bunch of space enthusiasts asking about Mars isn’t going to change public perception of Tesla in the slightest. Not everything is a vast PR conspiracy. You say you have a strong suspicion that it was intentionally focused. Did the fact that it says “about BFR” in the title give it away? Of course it’s focused.