4 ms·
Perhaps they haven't edited leaks, but it's pretty obvious Wikileaks has some biases, particularly anti-war. The branding of the Iraq airstrike video as "Collat
by tlrobinson 16y ago
Perhaps they haven't edited leaks, but it's pretty obvious Wikileaks has some biases, particularly anti-war. The branding of the Iraq airstrike video as "Collateral Murder" stained their credibility, IMO.
The fact that they don't edit/omit parts of leaks also says nothing about which leaks they choose to publish.
That said, I think it's a valuable service, I just wish they remained an unbiased source of leaked information. Of course, journalism is rarely unbiased.
- loewenskind 16y ago>but it's pretty obvious Wikileaks has some biases, particularly anti-war We know that Sadam did not have any WMDs. We know that Iraq didn't have or support terrorists. We know that our government knew these things before going to war. Being "anti" such a war isn't "bias". It's the only moral option. If someone reports on a murderer being convicted do they have an "anti-murder bias"?
- tlrobinson 16y agoUgh, I'm not going to get into this argument on HN.
- loewenskind 16y agoArguments are either about differences in opinion or one side trying to correct the ignorance of another party (aka educate). You can't have an "opinion" about facts. Facts are simply facts and if you disagree with them you are simply ignorant of them. So to have an argument (at least the good kind) here you would have to either (a) make the case that one of my "We know" statements is wrong or (b) make the case that there is some moral ambiguity given (a). If (a) holds then that means the US attacked a more-or-less random country (or worse, a specific country for reasons which we have to hide). I think one would have a rather large burden trying to prove that to be morally ambiguous.
- EliRivers 16y ago> it's pretty obvious Wikileaks has some biases, particularly anti-war Who exactly does not have an anti-war bias? Mass-murdering psychopaths? Insane dictators? Anyone who likes killing other people?
- tlrobinson 16y agoYeah, that was a poor choice of words. Calling that video "Collateral Murder" promotes their view that the airstrike was "murder", which is not clear. I'm only saying they should present the information and leave their opinion out of it.
- brl 16y ago> I'm only saying they should present the information and leave their opinion out of it. They do both. Feel free to take their complete source material and republish it with your own analysis. There is no other media organization in the world which gives you this opportunity.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- doodyhead 16y agoI'd go so far as to say that journalism is never unbiased and I don't see how it could ever be otherwise.