3 ms·
The books referenced in the linked article appear to discuss the topic in historical/anthropological context. I haven't read them yet but from the reviews I hav
by neonnoodle 9y ago
The books referenced in the linked article appear to discuss the topic in historical/anthropological context. I haven't read them yet but from the reviews I have read, they look promising.
As a teenager I read the novels of Daniel Quinn (known best for Ishmael), which is non-scholarly and has its problems. However, it prompted me to pursue a degree in bioanthropology. Most of the enthographic literature is consistent with the hypothesis that people don't willingly join civilization (city-based, hierarchical societies) when given the choice. Civilization has its clear advantages but its externalities have not nearly been solved.
But seriously, the domain of anthropology (cultural as much as biological) is where all relevant scholarship has been done. People make fun of anthropology for not being STEMy enough, but as a field it has a 100+ year history of delivering the goods. There's a classic essay by Marshal Sahlins called "The Original Affluent Society" that has been both influential and controversial. You can also look into the distinction between hoe-based farming and plow-based farming.