3 ms·
Worse. What - anecdotally - seems to happen is that these are areas reserved for lower income neighborhoods. The well to do reap the benefits of having cheap l
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
Worse. What - anecdotally - seems to happen is that these are areas reserved for lower income neighborhoods.
The well to do reap the benefits of having cheap labor nearby, pat themselves on the back for their generosity and kindness, and only lose occasionally if there's a flood. On the other hand, such floods devastate those areas for years if not decades. The destroy/rebuild cycle is simply breakeven. It pairs so well with poverty. A pairing the well to do rarely see.
- scarface74 9y agoThat wouldn’t be a bad idea - as long as there is full disclosure. To save money, I might rent in a place like that and make sure I have no valuables that I couldn’t take with me in my car. It’s rare that flooding in those areas happen without enough warning to get to safety.
- yk 9y agoEven with full disclosure, what is a poor person supposed to do? It is precisely the rich who could mitigate the risk, by either buying insurance or by building to a high enough standard. Poor people have to hope for the best, because the savings go directly to other necessities.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYou might. If you have a choice. That's often a pretty big if. Furthermore, any aid is often to rebuild not relocate. It's hard to break that cycle when the systrm promotes it.
- scarface74 9y agoEven with full disclosure, what is a poor person supposed to do? It is precisely the rich who could mitigate the risk, by either buying insurance or by building to a high enough standard. Poor people have to hope for the best, because the savings go directly to other necessities. That’s why I specifically said “rent”. If you only rent, don’t keep a lot of valuables that you can’t move at the drop of a dime in your car, what would the harm be? This also pre-supposes that the government is willing to help with temporary housing. If they are willing to help the owners of $500,000 plus homes, why not spend much less and help the poor with temporary housing assistance? In my case, when I first graduated from college and living on my own, why would I have cared if my apartment flooded? I could have put my clothes and my computer in my car taken the rent money I was paying and stay in an extended stay until I found another place. I wouldn’t care about my 20 year old bedroom set, my sleeper sofa, or my computer desk I bought from Walmart.
- calimac 9y agoDo you commenters have any concept of property ownership? MORTGAGE LENDERS REQUIRE FLOOD INSURANCE IN THESE AREAS.
- dizzystar 9y agoIf you are working two part-time jobs earning $8 / hour, renting is your only option. The poor often don't have enough food to eat for the week, much less own a car. They wouldn't own much either.
- scarface74 9y agoDo you commenters have any concept of property ownership? MORTGAGE LENDERS REQUIRE FLOOD INSURANCE IN THESE AREAS. They require below market value flood insurance that is heavily subsidized by taxpayers.
- mulmen 9y agoWhat do you think development in flood-endangered areas would do to the supply of affordable housing in other areas?
- pmorici 9y agoThe article is talking about upper middle class people.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoRight. But that's the exception not the rule. And that is worth mentioning. Else too many people continue to b Perpetuate the myth that poverty is a choice. But, as far as the article, you're correct. Thx.