2 ms·
Ontario is the most populous Canadian province, which I didn't know, with about 14,000,000 people. That is a bit more than twice the population of the Houston m
by mcguire 9y ago
Ontario is the most populous Canadian province, which I didn't know, with about 14,000,000 people. That is a bit more than twice the population of the Houston metro area.
The problem in Houston isn't construction in a flood prone area (the whole place is flood prone) but that construction upstream puts more drainage downstream. With Ontario's policy, construction of a suburb 50 miles away may make an existing neighborhood worthless.
- mabbo 9y ago> construction of a suburb 50 miles away may make an existing neighborhood worthless That would only happen if that suburb were being built in an existing flood plain. Ontario's policies aren't just about being near cities, it's the whole province. The little I know on the topic is because I married a water resources engineer. Her previous job was up north of Toronto, working at a conservation authority, telling developers that no, they can't build at all on that part of the land and also the part they can build on, they must add additional stormwater management ponds. The entire province is working to protect everyone.
- mcguire 9y ago"That would only happen if that suburb were being built in an existing floodplain." Actually, it isn't. Take a look at a map of the area around the reservoirs in question: https://encrypted.google.com/maps/place/Barker+Reservoir/@29.7862475,-95.7190335,13z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x8640d9562dc792f7:0x643beed24e124577!8m2!3d29.7696735!4d-95.6463348?hl=en https://encrypted.google.com/maps/place/Barker+Reservoir/@29... They are both completely surrounded by Houston. When they were built, everything upstream was prairie. Rain falling on that area would mostly be absorbed or cause localized ponding. The rest would enter the river in question, Buffalo Bayou, I believe. (Wikipedia has a dandy map of the Buffalo Bayou watershed: (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_Bayou https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_Bayou). It's interesting to note that it's almost entirely contained between the 99 "Grand parkway"(?) and Houston---I'm old, I remember when there was farmland between Katy and Houston.) Now, much of the area upstream has been converted to less permeable urban use, with the result that more water becomes run-off and ends up in the bayou. None of that construction is in any particular danger of flooding, itself. The article describes some of the legal and political fights that were involved in trying to say, "no, you cannot build any more net-impermeable in the Bayou watershed."
- andrewaylett 9y agoWith an integrated flood prevention policy, such as is supposed to exist in the UK and is claimed in Ontario, the people developing upstream would have to show that they've considered the effect on downstream, and mitigate any impact. Like the GP, I only really know about this because a family member does modelling in that area.
- Spooky23 9y agoTexas seems to have a unique ability to address that with these massive cities like Houston. Where I live, our city sewers, built 1890-1910 are getting 4-5x their design capacity as the outlying suburbs have been paved and populated. It’s a weird system because the county owns the treatment plants, but the piping is owned by the municipality. Localities (towns or cities) control zoning and approvals in most cases. So an impoverished city bears the burden and local impact of overwhelmed combined sewer flow (and cost for remediation like overflow basins) while the burbs bear little or no cost. At least in Houston they at least have the ability (if not the will) to control development.