13 ms·
The real roots of early city states may rip up the textbooks
- j_m_b 9y agoWouldn't surprise me at all if government was born from coercion of the individual to the needs of the state.. it is after all the definition of government.
- drharby 9y agoA government by the people, for the people? Ring any bells? Something something consent of the governed?
- labster 9y agoWhen in the course of human events, something something, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor.
- coldtea 9y agoThe basic idea is that it would be better to coerce to the rules/needs of a state, than to the arbitrary needs and whims of random powerful persons, teams of thugs, enemy tribes, etc. And it got even better when people could elect and somewhat control the state.
- pjc50 9y agoBefore the state, the coercion of the family.
- forapurpose 9y ago> it is after all the definition of government It's necessary for government (more specifically, at least for one context, a definition of sovereignty is a monopoly on violence and justice). But the definition is much more than that. It's also collective decision-making. I don't follow the law - even ones I disagree with - and pay my taxes because I'm coerced, but because I believe very strongly in the rule of law, I respect the decisions of my fellow citizens - even ones I disagree with, and I'm proud to participate.
- JoBrad 9y agoBut if you don’t believe in it, you are coerced, either by being evicted or forced to comply.
- xj9 9y agoit is still coercive because you don't have the option to opt-out and you were never asked to opt-in. you may not comply because of coercion, but if you decide you disagree a do not comply there are plenty of guns waiting to make sure you change your mind.
- forapurpose 9y ago> you were never asked to opt-in I certainly was. My neighbors and I elected someone to represent us on the matter, there was a public debate about the law before it was passed and I told my representative how I wanted them to vote, and our representative's job is up for review in a year.
- chongli 9y agoGovernment was born from the necessity to manage and defend grain stockpiles. Compared to hunted/foraged food, grain could be stored for long periods of time and its high energy density made it a prime target for thieves/marauders.
- trgv 9y agoThat's one theory. I find myself wondering what exactly differentiates a "government" from a "family council" or "tribal leadership" or whatever other phrase you want to use to describe an "authority-wielding-body with a monopoly on force." I think "governments" are as old as people, and probably older. Many social animals have leaders who dominate the rest of the herd. My feeling is that governments have always been here, they've just gotten bigger and maybe a little more sinister.
- chongli 9y agoAs with many things, the line is blurry. I think governments really start to take shape once you get past Dunbar's number [0]. When people no longer know everybody, they need to rely on rules and designated authority figures to settle disputes. I don't know of any way around that. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number
- icebraining 9y agoThe seems suspect; after all, the parliaments and other legislative chambers of most countries are larger than Dunbar's number.
- chongli 9y agoParliaments operate based on rules with a central authority, usually called the speaker, who acts to settle disputes. Parliaments do not operate like an extended family.
- 9y ago
- neonnoodle 9y agoThe forager/garden-farm way of life and the monocrop agriculture way of life are mutually exclusive. The compulsory city-states that we associate with "civilization" depends fundamentally on taking over land for monocrops. The agro-forager way of life depends on managed biodiversity, with many interdependent species. Thus throughout history you have the repeated pattern of displacement, slavery, genocide, "re-education" and oppression of foraging people and garden farmers by monocrop-powered militarized states. It's been a 10,000 year global war, and it is close to having been "won" by civilization. The losers, of course, are all indigenous people worldwide, as well as the basic livability of our planet and probably 80% of its species. The irony, of course, is that monocrop agriculture isn't sustainable. It's had a good run, but we're coming up against some really tough limits soon. The Green Revolution bought some time, but it's probably going to be a very hard landing. All that biodiversity took millions of years to radiate, and only a short time to destroy. Human cultural diversity took 100,000-500,000 years to develop many different of ways of life, and only a short time to liquidate. I only hold out hope that enough species, ecosystems and cultures are left to help guide civilization toward something sustainable. We can do this the easy way or the hard way.
- mancerayder 9y agoThat's an interesting take and seems like a compelling explanation about the 'struggle' between monocrop and biodiverse cultures. Do you have handy any references or other further reading on precisely that topic?
- neonnoodle 9y agoThe books referenced in the linked article appear to discuss the topic in historical/anthropological context. I haven't read them yet but from the reviews I have read, they look promising. As a teenager I read the novels of Daniel Quinn (known best for Ishmael), which is non-scholarly and has its problems. However, it prompted me to pursue a degree in bioanthropology. Most of the enthographic literature is consistent with the hypothesis that people don't willingly join civilization (city-based, hierarchical societies) when given the choice. Civilization has its clear advantages but its externalities have not nearly been solved. But seriously, the domain of anthropology (cultural as much as biological) is where all relevant scholarship has been done. People make fun of anthropology for not being STEMy enough, but as a field it has a 100+ year history of delivering the goods. There's a classic essay by Marshal Sahlins called "The Original Affluent Society" that has been both influential and controversial. You can also look into the distinction between hoe-based farming and plow-based farming.
- finnh 9y agoThe New Yorker recently covered the same topics and the bushman book as well: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/09/18/the-case-against-civilization https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/09/18/the-case-again...
- radicaldreamer 9y agoLife might not be nasty, brutish, and short for some lucky bushmen, but for most it sure seems to suck: "Bushmen health, in general, is not good though: 50% of children die before the age of 15; 20% die within their first year (mostly of gastrointestinal infections). Average life expectancy is about 45-50 years"
- ThomPete 9y agoIt important to remember though that the reason average life was 45-50 was because of all the people who died early in life. If you actually managed to hit 30 there was a good chance you would make it up in your 60-70ies.
- radicaldreamer 9y agoThose are current stats, only 10% of bushmen live past 60.
- jonnycomputer 9y agomost bushmen aren't healthy hunter-gatherers any more.
- msabalau 9y agoHigh childhood mortality, and adult life expectancy until the 40s doesn't necessarily have to be characterized as nasty or brutish. It was the norm for most of human existence, until the new stone age (When the undergraduate simplification "old people live until 70, and life expectancy is really about child mortality" kicks in.) Perhaps unexpectedly, anthropologists visiting such societies often perceive them as remarkably vibrant and healthy, because so much of the population is in their teens and twenties. “Were they beautiful? We were all beautiful. We were in our twenties.” ― Steve Martin
- forapurpose 9y ago> High childhood mortality, and adult life expectancy until the 40s doesn't necessarily have to be characterized as nasty or brutish. > It was the norm for most of human existence The second statement isn't an argument against the first. In fact the original 'nasty, brutish, and short' quote, I think by Winston Churchill, stated that it was the norm. Slavery and monarchy, not freedom and democracy, was the norm for most of human history. Epidemics and famine, not the CDC and obesity, used to be the norm.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoApparently the poli sci and anthropology guys aren't mixing with the history profs very much. Most history professors I've known refer to the dark ages as the "so-called dark ages" because that time period served as proof-positive that you can have civilized society without the state.
- Infernal 9y agoAre there any books or papers you could recommend which explore this view of the dark ages - say that compare/contrast the type of civilized society that emerges in the presence of a state with one that emerges in its absence?
- travmatt 9y agoIf you're interested in the formation of states you'd probably be interested in Francis Fukuyama's "Origins of Political Order". He starts from small bands of hunter-gatherers and explores some factors that drove political development from those disparate bands up through the French Revolution.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoOff the top of my head, anything Carrol Quigley. Regarding what my professors read, I will have to inquire. http://www.carrollquigley.net/books.htm http://www.carrollquigley.net/books.htm http://www.carrollquigley.net/book-reviews/history_freedom_western_world.htm http://www.carrollquigley.net/book-reviews/history_freedom_w... Oh, and Durant's "The Age of Faith" is also worth a read.
- unscaled 9y agoI think this is yet another misconception that might come out of theoretical political science (or the ignorant press). The political difference between the Early Middle Ages (a.k.a the dark ages) and the Roman empire wasn't the lack of state, but a very different type of state. The Early Middle Ages in Europe saw a large number of short-lived monarchies and a few long-lived ones. The Catholic Church rivaled and often surpassed secular states in its power. Throughout the entire middle ages, for most of the peasantry, interaction with the state in the broadest sense that we have today (i.e. with the king) was scarce. Local rulers, dignitaries and institutions, had large autonomy and more direct influence on the daily lives of peasants. Free cities are a good example of completely autonomous sovereignty. If they were chartered, the local princes had little power over them - but chartered cities only appear in the very end of the dark ages. Anyway, I recommend 'Medieval Cities: Their Origins and the Revival of Trade' by Henri Pirenne. It's an old book and there's definitely more up to date research, but Henri Pirenne is a brilliant historian and writer and he paints a very vivid picture of what the "so-called dark ages" in Europe were like.
- solidsnack9000 9y agoAn examination of the habits of fishes, insects, &c, will readily show that being “the fittest” is often an incredibly, tough harsh life.
- navigator01 9y ago>“For at least 4000 years, there were settled communities but no evidence of state power” Well that doesn't mean state power isn't necessary for large scale communities. It just shows that in the thousands of years after the dawn of agriculture communities were too small to require a state framework to exist. As community scale increased, states became necessary.
- unscaled 9y ago"Around 12,000 BC, the world’s population stood at between two and four million; by 2000 BC, it was around 25 million. But the vast majority of people had no contact with states as late as the end of the 15th century – Europe’s middle ages." This seems extremely off to me. In the 15th century CE most people on Earth were most definitely sedentary farmers or nomadic pastoralists living under one sort of state or another. That wasn't necessarily a large kingdom (though tens of millions lived in China, where kingdoms were quite large even when it was divided), and it's not like farmers knew or cared much about the politics of their kings, but there was definitely a state, and even when there wasn't one towns and villages had their own institutions and hierarchies that were quite different from the egalitarian lifestyle of hunter gatherers. To put that in another words, in agricultural societies, even in the most remote and independent villages, women and men were not equal, fathers and grown-up sons were not equal, brothers were not equal and different families were not equal. These societies are generally fiercely patriarchal - in the sense that females were viewed as property of the male head of the household, not in the sense the women were not allowed to hunt. This concept would entirely alien in hunter-gatherer societies and in most of them so is the very concept of property itself.
- belorn 9y agoThere is no historical evidence that agricultural societies were patriarchal, nor that females were viewed as property of the male head of the household. If we look at survived native cultures, the key observation is culture and traditional gave women and men separated roles and responsibilities with the elders of each as guides and authority. The elder women decided, taught and guide the other women and girls in the group, while the elder men did the same for the men and boys. Men were not allowed to interfere with the domain of the elder women, and women were not allowed to interfere within the domain of the elder men. In order for it to be a fiercely patriarchal where females were viewed as property of the male head of the household, it would mean that men had the power to decide what women should and should not do. This fly in contrast to when culture and tradition fully dictate how people should live their life.