3 ms·
I have to disagree on both counts: 1) Preserving a reliable institution of private property is also a "public goods problem", and thieves (of physical goods) a
by SilasX 9y ago
I have to disagree on both counts:
1) Preserving a reliable institution of private property is also a "public goods problem", and thieves (of physical goods) are free-riding in a very analogous sense (disrupting the very system that enables the production of things-worth-stealing). That free-riding is exactly what makes piracy intuitively feel like theft.
2) Enabling the down-low production of a drug does disrupt the monopoly that drug researchers depend on to justify doing that research. It is therefore likewise free-riding off of their work in discovering exactly which compounds (by which methods) produce useful drugs. Where a producer or a consumer obviates the monopoly isn't relevant.
Now, I agree that it's a matter of scale: a few hobbyists won't make a difference, but if one day someone magically made it possible to reliably produce Viagra in your basement, then Pfizer would definitely care about that and revise downward their estimates of future drug returns upon learning of the possibility.
- r00fus 9y agoAre these outcomes you describe actually bad? While I believe in the rule of law, the fact is that law has been bent to serve the wealthy and powerful. Perhaps such lawbreaking is simply the symptom of the disease as Dr. Prasad says, which is (patent laws that allow current) drug pricing.
- SilasX 9y agoI was only speaking to rayiner's a) attempt to break the analogy between physical theft and piracy, and b) insistence that teaching DIY production of patented drugs "doesn't offend" the monopoly. But yes, I strongly believe that it's a very bad economic model that insists that drugs -- or any physical good for that matter -- should (in any sense of "should") be sold at marginal production cost.
- r00fus 9y agoI disagree. Not sure how you got from my position to yours. The patent system is broken. IP laws are far too powerful and some things should really be sold at marginal production cost + a small markup for distribution.
- SilasX 9y agoNo markup for cost of capital e.g. factory equipment to manufacture something?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]