3 ms·
Do we execute doctors for murder every time it's conceivably possible that a patient's death could have been avoided? The law is hardly ever consequentialist.
by closeparen 9y ago
Do we execute doctors for murder every time it's conceivably possible that a patient's death could have been avoided?
The law is hardly ever consequentialist. In almost any position where you can kill someone by mistake in the course of a legitimate activity, punishing the killer requires evidence that they were unusually reckless.
- Filligree 9y ago> The law is hardly ever consequentialist. I would actually argue the opposite. The law is almost always consequentalist, it merely has a wider view of the consequences. Punishing someone for a mistake when they weren't unusually reckless would have negative consequences for society that outweigh the potential benefits of doing so, therefore we don't.
- m3rc 9y agoWe 100% hold doctors accountable for killing patients if it was through negligence.
- closeparen 9y agoCorrect. We punish doctors for negligence, not for the outcome alone.