10 ms·
I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. I mean I get it, greed and flexible morality result in exploitation of the masses, but
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. I mean I get it, greed and flexible morality result in exploitation of the masses, but it is not unique to tech.
During the dot.com boom it was pretty clear that there were people here in the Bay Area whose only goal was to sell some investors on an idea, pump it up, take it public on a story, pocket some big profits and then blow town. My friends and I called it the "Invasion of the MBAs" but it really was the invasion of people who want to make easy money and they don't care who they hurt doing it. After things blew up and the only people getting investment were people trying to actually build products it calmed way down. This 'type' of person seems to seek out other avenues when there is real work to be done.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- joering2 9y agoIts quite different with Wall-street tho. In Bay Area with your freshly mint MBA, over the weekend you could put together power-point presentation, pitch it on Monday as a "big shot with incredible idea and amazing connections" and get funded by Friday. Meanwhile to be selling the same BS on the stock market you actually had to had a stock, who got on the NYSE/NASDAQ board first, and that means there has been actually a physical company with employees and everything in place.
- moomin 9y agoI think the reason that article doesn't run in the NYT is because it's accepted wisdom. A much more likely article is "You may hate Wall Street, but you'd miss it if it was gone."
- jrs95 9y agoEssentially every major institution is like this, the NY Times and the rest of the media included. We should probably be less fixated on which particular groups of corporations are 'good' or 'bad' and deal with the underlying problems.
- pm90 9y agoIt would be a total non-issue if they did come out saying that openly though. Probably it started off with Google's "do no evil" motto; I can't think of any tech companies that promoted themselves as a force for social good rather than a pure business. Except maybe Apple under Steve Jobs.
- humanrebar 9y ago> I can't think of any tech companies that promoted themselves as a force for social good rather than a pure business. It's actually a trope for SV companies. It was lampooned in season 1 episode 1 of the show Silicon Valley: > And yes, we're disrupting digital media, but most importantly we're making the world a better place. Through constructing elegant hierarchies for maximum code reuse and extensibility. http://siliconvalleyism.com/silicon-valley-quote.php?id=206 http://siliconvalleyism.com/silicon-valley-quote.php?id=206
- Applejinx 9y agoWord of warning: I went and read tons of Silicon Valley quotes, and then returned to this thread, and struggled to tell the difference :)
- engagement 9y agoWall Street does not claim to improve the world. Zuckerberg for example claims that he has some goal of changing the world for the better. Note, I think this is all a little silly when it clearly comes down to rich individuals that define most of the giving. Gates couldn’t have done so much without microsoft.
- binarymax 9y agoNot true. Plenty of people in the finance world consider the driving force of capitalism to fuel progress by increasing value to the economy.
- abakker 9y agoand by improving the allocation of resources to growth areas. The thing is, the technology industry, and the finance industry do useful, good work. The trouble really comes from an overreach of corporate power. poor regulation and lousy, antisocial corporate governance are not the problems of their industries, they are the problem of our government.
- tannhauser23 9y agoDude, the head of Goldman Sachs said he'a doing God's work: https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/goldman-chief-says-he-is-just-doing-gods-work/ https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/goldman-chief-says-h...
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoCalvanism? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvinism
- bogomipz 9y agoDude, it was totally snark and the media left out some important context: http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2009/11/world_not_laughing_at_lloyd_bl.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2009/11/world_not_laugh...
- 9y ago
- ithinkinstereo 9y ago> I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. The comparison here isn't very apt because wallstreeters don't really pitch themselves as visionary innovators out to "save the world" and "do no evil." I mean sure the PR departments of all the bulge brackets will spin their typical corporate BS, but generally speaking, Wall Street is pretty self-aware. In comparison, tying your mission to some humanistic cause is basically a pre-requisite for a tech company/startup. Case in point from yesterday's WSJ coverage of Outcome [1]: Outcome has said its mission is to “activate the best health outcome possible for every person in the world” and provide "actionable health intelligence at the moment of care." In practice, it puts flat screens and tablets in doctors’ offices and gets paid by pharmaceutical companies to run ads on them. 1. http://archive.is/QZnTN http://archive.is/QZnTN
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times Well. The New York Times is generally for more financial regulation. If you're calling for a FINRA, SEC, CFPB, House Financial Services Committee, Senate Banking Committee and state-by-state financial services regulatory equivalents for tech, then you'll probably find yourself in agreement with (a) the New York Times, (b) most of the media and (c) a growing fraction of legislators and the American electorate. Partly because of what happened. Largely because of the flippant response the offending companies, and our Silicon Valley culture as a whole, has had to the complaints.
- mobilio 9y agoSame is in Wall St. "Greed is good!"
- macNchz 9y ago>I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. NY Times regularly publishes very critical opinion pieces on Wall St behavior. Here's a particularly good one from last year, "When You Dial 911 and Wall Street Answers", Part 1 of a 5 part teardown on how PE firms have wormed their way into critical services in search of profits: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/26/business/dealbook/when-you-dial-911-and-wall-street-answers.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/26/business/dealbook/when-yo...
- wallace_f 9y agoOk not bad, but it isn't really fair. The real villains are not PE firms (people who play with their own money and don't care who they hurt trying to make more), but the commercial-investment banking empires (people who play with other people's money, get the world's cheapest, most unlimited insurance--err no: bail out policy, from a private bank that somehow swindled the American people into controlling its printing press (the Fed), gets direct financing from the Fed, are filled with collusion and corruption with government, and have the ability to destroy the entire economy). After every election there are always the same winners: Wall St is one of the biggest ones.
- SilasX 9y agoPE firms do pretty villainous things. "Oh, burdened by unfunded pension obligations? Those are pretty much unranked next to debt, so sell off all the good assets to a carbon copy firm, default on everything, and pass the pensioners onto the government." IIRC that was pretty much Bain's MO.
- wallace_f 9y agoThey do. They're just not on the robber barron level of the commercial banks, which steal truly unholy amounts of money from American citizens. Reasonable people have put the cost of the financial crisis at 6-30 trillion, or more (6 being the lower bound of the Fed's very own estimate). The higher figure is $93,000/per citizen, and it very will could be more than that.(1) That is only the start of the story. Ever wonder why your money devalues every day? That value is not magically disappearing due to some mystical force called inflation: someone is capturing that value. Thanks to High Priest of the Harvard-Wall Street Order, Gregory Mankiw, the Fed even has an influential academic paper that craftily provides a logical dogma to minimize theft through seignorage, and how muxh the public really is being taken for. There are good reasons people from Aaron Swarz to Milton Friedman really, really wanted to get rid of the Fed. 1-https://www.cnbc.com/id/101022718 https://www.cnbc.com/id/101022718
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoI highly recommend the book "Exit Strategy" by Douglas Rushkoff. Although it is fiction, it is an entertaining read of the attitude you describe during the dot.com boom. I remember reading it a chapter at a time, as it was released, I think weekly, on yil.com.
- gnicholas 9y ago> I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. Talking to friends in NYC, they say that the "Silicon Valley is evil" trope plays well there because New York is heavily finance-based, and finance has been slammed while tech has ascended. Also note that Amazon is included in "Silicon Valley", even though they have never been headquartered in CA.
- ashwinaj 9y ago> I wonder how "Wall Street is not your friend" would play in the NY Times. That's exactly what I had in mind when I was reading the article! Businesses are in existence to make money, it's up to us (which includes govt. regulations) to reign them in when necessary. This shouldn't be a surprise that businesses are exploiting the masses.
- aaroninsf 9y agoThe generalized case is both obviously the case, and not an examined axiom in contemporary politics: corporations operating without a value function that incorporates the public good and the commons, are not your friend. Well, unless 'you' are one of the very few (statistically speaking) benefiting. It's neither impossible nor unreasonable to constrain organizational behavior to incorporate collective goals. It's just politically toxic in an America where self interest has been cultivated to be the ultimate moral litmus test. That economic theories predicated on the aggregated consequence of self interest providing for collective benefit have been utterly disproven has not affected the received ideology. Who would want to question the belief that acting in their own benefit is not morally unimpeachable? QED the lionized cowboy culture at Über, to name an egregious example among a bottomless pool of them.
- WalterBright 9y ago> a value function that incorporates the public good and the commons That would be providing a product that people are freely willing to pay for.
- dredmorbius 9y agoHeroin?
- alexryan 9y ago> I mean I get it, greed and flexible morality result in exploitation of the masses, but it is not unique to tech. With wall street, we knew that we were dealing with people of low character because they were open about it. “greed is good” was the motto With silicon valley, the tech companies portrayed themselves as do-gooder “don’t be evil” types on a mission of contribution and some of us were naive enough to believe it. Big difference. I think we tend to hate those who betray our trust us more strongly than those who are honest about their intentions.