9 ms·
Why Isn’t It a Crime to Kill a Cyclist with a Car?
- onewhonknocks 9y agoIt absolutely can be a crime.
- walshemj 9y agoyep causing bodily harm by "wanton or furious driving" is how its put in the UK
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PoachedSausage 9y agoThere is also "Death by Dangerous Driving", however the sentences in the UK for causing the death of pedestrians and cyclists are bad. You could end up being sent to prison for 5 years and a 5 year driving ban while in prison. If you kill someone by dangerous driving then you should be banned for life.
- walshemj 9y agoNot for cyclists oddly enough
- PoachedSausage 9y agoDriving vehicles requires that you undergo training and obtain a licence, it could be argued that cyclists should have to do the same, but laws need to be proportional. Several ton metal boxes can kill people a lot easier than cyclists.
- andyjohnson0 9y agoIn the UK the offence would be Causing Death by Dangerous Driving [1], and it only applies to drivers of motorised vehicles. The "wanton or furious driving" charge that was used in the recent case of Kim Briggs's death [2] was used because the death was caused by a cyclist. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causing_death_by_dangerous_driving https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causing_death_by_dangerous_dri... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/sep/18/cyclist-charlie-alliston-jailed-for-18-months-over-death-of-pedestrian https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/sep/18/cyclist...
- walshemj 9y agono its not which is why they used such an archaic statute - there is a campaign to extend death by dangerous driving to cyclists
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- m3rc 9y agoCase after case in the US has shown that all you need to do is claim it was an accident and you'll receive the most minor of slaps on the wrist.
- bqe 9y agoIt isn't just cyclists, but pedestrians too. The best way to murder someone in America is to run them over with your car and say it was an accident. The other person, being dead, can't testify otherwise. There's a particularly egregious example of an NYC taxi driver killing a child when the pedestrians had the right of way[1]. No charges other than a minor traffic ticket. [1]: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/cabbie-mowed-manhattan-boy-traffic-fine-article-1.2184010 http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/cabbie-mowed-m...
- Amezarak 9y agoYou can also kill someone in another car and not be charged and convicted, unless you did it purposefully or were driving with reckless disregard for human life. It's not that pedestrians and cyclists are treated as a special case.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoRight, it's that being in a car is treated as a special case where you can kill someone and the legal system mostly doesn't care unless it's blindingly obvious that it was intentional.
- smsm42 9y agoIt's not a special case - you can't convict somebody of a felony murder if there was no intent to kill and it happened by accident. I.e. if you were standing on a ladder, and it suddenly collapsed and you fell on top of somebody and that person died, it's not a murder. Even if a car is not involved.
- choko 9y agoThat's also known as "innocent until proven guilty". Should it rather be the driver's fault to prove that it was an accident instead of intentional? How might one go about proving such a thing?
- lorenzhs 9y ago
- rhino369 9y agoLike the article says, "Criminal law punishes bad intentions and bad acts, not traffic accidents.” Accidents happen. There is no reason to ruin two lives instead of one, by harshly punishing another person. If driver A takes the .002% chance they'll cause an accident while driving on the phone and drive B takes the same .002% chance, it makes no sense to throw B in jail and let A off with a 50 dollar fine just because driver B actually hit someone. Drive B should be liable for all medical costs and lost income. But society gains nothing by punishing her. It's just a way to make us all feel more control. Accidents only happen to bad criminals! Good folks like us would never have an accident!
- serf 9y ago"Like the article says, "Criminal law punishes bad intentions and bad acts, not traffic accidents.” Well, the article is quoting the attorney of the person who ran over a cyclist, so it's fairly narrow in scope. The law finds accidents worthy of punishment everywhere, everyday -- regardless of provable ill will. But I absolutely agree with what you've said. There is little to gain by punishing the perpetrator of an accident. The problem arises when the truly guilty use the facade of accident to commit crimes that they want to commit.
- grey 9y agoA while ago it was suggested to me to mentally translate "accident" to "collision" in context of cars hitting cyclists. Most collisions with cyclists are easily avoidable, and caused by negligence, impatience or ignorance. Treating collisions as unavoidable, unintentional mistakes relieves drivers of a lot of the inherent responsibility of controlling a vehicle. Watch the road. Respect other users of the road. Be patient, safe, and focused.
- notauser 9y agoBy harshly punishing drivers you provide a deterrent against the next accident. It makes sure that drivers have both an atruistic reason (preventing an accident) and selfish reason (preventing their license being revoked) to pay attention. Also - banning a driver isn't really a punishment as they'll get to discover how much fun it is to cycle to work and gain the life-long benefits of exercise and a friendly, social, activity :-)
- notauser 9y agoIn the UK, we've recently had a very rare case of a cyclists killing a pedestrian. The cyclist was highly irrsponsible - he had only one brake, and the law requires two. As a result he was jailed for 18 months [1]. I think his conviction is reasonable. But it's highly unfair that the same standard isn't applied to drunk drivers, or drivers using their mobile phone, or drivers who have failed to renew their mandatory annual safety test (MOT) certificate. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2017/aug/23/motorist-would-not-have-landed-cyclists-wanton-and-furious-driving-charge https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2017/aug/2...
- kuschku 9y agoIt is in many countries. For example, in Germany, in any situation where a driver and a pedestrian or cyclist crash, the driver always has partial fault. In cases where the cyclist or pedestrian dies, it almost always is a crime for the driver. In some situations, when the driver is driving recklessly, it becomes murder. On February 27, a driver was sentenced to lifelong imprisonment for murder by car: http://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/zeitgeschehen/2017-02/berlin-illegales-autorennen-fahrer-urteil http://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/zeitgeschehen/2017-02/berlin... (that was two drivers doing an illegal car race, and hitting a car that wasn’t participating).
- vaseem 9y agoLaws like these are very dangerous.
- legulere 9y agoNot always, there are cases where the driver did everything right and still an accident happened: http://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/prozess-gegen-lkw-fahrer-warnung-an-alle-radfahrer-1.95367 http://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/prozess-gegen-lkw-fahrer...
- kuschku 9y agoAs the article you linked shows, there’s a different burden of proof in that case, though.
- sharpercoder 9y agoIn the Netherlands, it goes as following: - Car drivers' fault? -> Insurance of car driver pays - Cyclist' fault? 1. Cyclist younger then 14? It's the car drivers' fault. In any case. Drivers should expect younger cyclists to behave unexpected. 2. Bicycle driver older then 14? 50% of damage is drivers' fault. Unless cyclist does reckless things the car driver cannot anticipate on (e.g. cycling through red traffic light over a busy intersection where drivers drive fast). - Car driver & cyclist made mistakes? -> Cyclist is able to get more then 50% of damages depending on the situation.
- DanielleMolloy 9y agoAs the consequences of an accident are far worse for the cyclists in almost all cases I think the Netherlands' solution is a very reasonable one. So far I only heard a few fanatic car drivers complain about this. I think to understand you actually need to bike on a regular basis.
- dogma1138 9y agoNL solution isn’t unique 50% of the damage goes to the car driver is pretty standard in insurance claims when 2 wheel vehicles are involved this also applies to motor bikes. I had a motorbike rear end like 6-7 years ago and he went flying and my insurance had to pay for 50% of the claim or about and I’m not Dutch. The 14 year old case might be unique to NL but even that I’m no so sure.
- the_common_man 9y ago> 1. Cyclist younger then 14? It's the car drivers' fault. In any case. Drivers should expect younger cyclists to behave unexpected. Do cycles have some sort of tag (like an 'L' sign), which helps identify such cyclists?
- skepticaldrunk 9y agoThey usually have a kid on them.
- xeromal 9y ago"To the three of them, it appeared as if Norton was trying to move her car to the side of the road. But in the process, she drove over Morgan’s head, with her right front tire placed squarely on top. (Norton’s attorney says that she was in a state of shock.) They screamed at Norton to back the car up, which she did, but after getting out of the car a second time, she reentered the vehicle. “I was horrified that she was trying to drive it again,” Richardson says. “I was screaming at her through the passenger-side window, which was down. She was trying to put her keys in the ignition… I was trying to reach into the sedan to grab her keys.”" I got sick reading this.
- Sholmesy 9y agoSicker when you realise she was on the phone the entire time.
- fencepost 9y ago> Sicker when you realise she was on the phone the entire time. THAT may be one of the things that starts to make a difference - in the time since that event many states and municipalities have put in much tougher 'distracted driving' laws that may be enforceable in a lot of accidents and which may improve results in civil cases.
- FireBeyond 9y agoYeah, as an EMS provider, entirely possible she was in shock (of the mental sense, not physiological). Also entirely possible she was being told to leave, or something. You wouldn't (or maybe you would) believe the number of times we've shown up to DUI injury accidents where a spouse has shown up "coincidentally" and is trying to ferry their drunk partner into their car before police or fire get there. In one case, while we were checking out such a drunk driver, the cop looked over and his wife was about 5 feet away, gesticulating at her chest and then a choking sound, repeatedly. He had a confused look and then started complaining of chest pain. A waste of time, but counterproductive for them both - she/they were thinking they'd lessen his blood alcohol by feigning a medical condition, but instead an ECG was run, all clear, but due to his continuing complaint he was transported by ambulance to hospital where the first thing done... was a blood draw.
- gnu8 9y agoWe need to ban assault cars at once! No honest person needs a 300+ horsepower tank powered by a fuel that is literally explosive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lotyrin 9y agoEspecially the ones with the arm rests that go up.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoAgreed, ban manually-driven cars as quickly as feasible.
- vaseem 9y agoIt can be very difficult for someone to notice a bicycle on 40~55mph roads. Cyclists are definitely taking a risk. I wear Neon cycling shirt and avoid peak time when cycling. Laws aside, I don't think Cyclists should block lanes esp' during peak traffic time. I actually would like a ban on main roads during rush hours, number of folks change lanes and create very dangerous situations for all.
- yardie 9y agoAs a cyclist I hate travelling on the main road. Not only do I feel guilty for slowing traffic but all it takes is one inattentive knucklehead to end my life. Yet, what choice do I have? Sidewalks are obstacle courses of pedestrians, trashbins, bus stops, sign posts, etc. Bicycle lanes are blocked by taxis/uber/lyft, delivery vans, double parked cars.
- Filligree 9y agoRiding on the sidewalk probably isn't even legal; you might hit a pedestrian. I know. I do it too, though I keep my speed down to a brisk walking pace unless I'm in an area where I know it's safe to speed up. Laws are laws, though... At least here in Dublin the cars are mostly good about keeping away, even if there aren't many bike trails.
- kylec 9y agoNot to be snarky, but have you considered driving or taking a taxi/Uber/Lyft? If you're going to spend a bunch of time on the main road, why not do it in a car?
- yardie 9y agoBecause as a citizen I'm entitled to use the road as well. The city decided that cars and bikes can share the lane so that is what I will do. Also, in my case, it takes the same amount of time to travel by bike as a car and costs a whole lot less.
- 9y ago
- excalibur 9y agoWhat really grinds my gears is the frequency with which cyclists are legally forced onto the roadway in a high-traffic area, when there is a perfectly good sidewalk available. Just assume that Bob is going to have an accident on his bike today. Would you rather see him struck by a car and become a likely fatality, or see him hit a pedestrian and cause a few scrapes and bruises? Why would you unnecessarily force people into a potentially deadly situation for the crime of riding a bicycle?
- notauser 9y agoSidewalks aren't flat, and they don't have priority at junctions. This makes them unsuitable for commuting or serious cycling. To make it a viable form of personal transport it's better to keep cyclists on the roads.
- tehwebguy 9y agoThis is ridiculous. Sidewalks are not thoroughfares - cyclists on the sidewalk put themselves in grave danger at virtually every intersection.
- Filligree 9y agoWithout commenting on whether or not it's legal, if you're cycling in the sidewalk then you should at least attempt to act like a pedestrian. This means waiting for a walk light at the crossing, and not cycling into the road at above a walking pace even if it happens to already be green. This is just common sense, really.
- tehwebguy 9y agoIntersections include more than just those with traffic lights.
- astrodust 9y agoIt is outright illegal to cycle on a sidewalk in many places. Here if you have a wheel diameter more than a foot you can't use the sidewalk. That exception is intended to allow little kids to use the sidewalk without issue. It's also extremely uncommon for cyclists to hit pedestrians, and even more uncommon for those collisions to lead to a fatality. There's just not enough kinetic energy involved. Joggers are nearly as likely to bowl someone over and kill them.
- tritium 9y agoAn accident is an accident, is an accident, is an accident. We've all had accidents, and we know what that feels like. Negligence, maliciousness and depravity all have clear definitions. There's no clear rule for discerning human intent and emotion, retrospectively, but it's outlines are often detectable through residual evidence. It is often obvious when an event required careful planning, contrasted against chaotic incidents that couldn't possibly be replicated if you tried. Sometimes, things are curiously a little bit in between. Most of reality is imperfect, and we have to accept that.
- astrodust 9y ago"I was just texting in my phone. I didn't mean to run over that lady." That is not an accident. These are not accidents. The very phrase "accident" leads to the sort of thinking you're espousing here. These are collisions. These are deaths. These are manslaughter. These are negligent homicide. These are avoidable. If you're operating a vehicle and not paying attention, not driving according to the road conditions, aren't keeping your vehicle in proper mechanical shape, or don't have sufficient training, you're a hazard and shouldn't be on the road. Period.
- gnu8 9y agoThat’s exactly the same as saying “I was just drunk. I didn’t mean to run over that lady.” When the driver deliberately impairs their ability to drive, they assume culpability for any accident that might occur.
- tritium 9y agoAh, so every collision is the product of a willful decision to enter into circumstances that place others in harms way, and may be readily equivocated to handling a loaded gun, with the intent to possibly destroy things, yes? And I suppose collisions are thus to be perceived as, not merely likely, but having been inevitable once they transpire, at least in the eyes of the law. So, every traffic infraction is the result of someone waking up and trying to do harm, or in some way cause a problem they may have inflicted (or intended to inflict) upon the world. And especially so, when proven guilty by a trustworthy legal system, immune to manipulation. Everyone is suicidal, everyone is self destructive, everyone is negligent, and these collisions are just representative of the moments in which such people succeed in fulfilling their desires. I see how it works now. Thanks for the enlightenment.
- tehwebguy 9y agoBecause nearly all US police have a perverse incentive to issue easy-revenue traffic tickets. From the article: > The New York City Police Department, for example, issued more than 96,000 citations to drivers in 2012 for excessive window tinting, which wasn’t an influence in any fatal or injurious crashes. > By comparison, according to a October 2013 Transportation Alternatives report, the NYPD issued fewer than 12 summonses a month in 2012 to drivers who failed to yield, one of the leading causes of injurious crashes in New York.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago> drivers who failed to yield, one of the leading causes of injurious crashes in New York. That's like saying "speed causes accidents". Yes, the accident probably would have been avoidable at 5mph. Yes, not cutting people off when taking a left turn would be nice but eventually you just have to make eye contact and floor it if you want to take a left turn (granted that's not a good example but "failure to yield" is a broad enough category to be useless).
- trjordan 9y agoAs pointed out in the article, it can be a crime, depending on jurisdiction and local laws. The problem is prosecuting that crime in the same way you'd process a murder with a knife, because the public doesn't see them the same way. Honestly, I get that. Driving a bike on a road with cars seems dangerous. I do it, and I don't want to die, but it's not the same as walking on the sidewalk or sitting in my yard. If there were bad choices made by the driver, then sure, let's prosecute. But passing a biker going 15mph on a 45mph road doesn't seem crazy. Going 72 in a 65 doesn't seem crazy. I like to think I'm an aware driver, and I haven't hit any bikers yet, but I've seen myself be two distracted moments away from hitting one. It's not crazy that I would be checking my maps app at the same time a police siren comes into view, leading me to miss the biker who'd just turned into the lane next to me. The problem seems to me that we've built both physical and social structures around roads being for cars. It needs to feel comfortable to bike while taking up a whole lane, both for bikers and cars. ("Drive at the speed bikers go" isn't reasonable, imho.) Bike lanes help a lot, and having a lot of bikers around helps a lot. But we can't just start with "killing a biker is deliberate murder", because it's simply not. It's old attitudes being applied to a new world, and I'd rather find a way to bring people into the new world than punish a few of them for making a mistake.
- Filligree 9y ago> It's not crazy that I would be checking my maps app at the same time a police siren comes into view, leading me to miss the biker who'd just turned into the lane next to me. Perhaps it's not crazy, but it is illegal. You're supposed to keep your eyes on the road, and looking at your smartphone is just as bad whether you're texting or using a map app. Phones have voice output for this reason. If you need to take your eyes off the road, then first stop. If you don't, and as a result hit someone, then yes, it's murder.
- jbob2000 9y agoPoor example on his part. The same situation could happen while changing the radio, adjusting AC, or even looking in a different mirror. The safety-dogmatism of "If you need to take your eyes off the road, then first stop" is not practical advice.
- greensoap 9y agoI don't really understand the article. The article suggests they are advocating for a blanket law. Are they saying that anytime an accident happens involving a car and a bike where the driver was at fault it should be a criminal prosecution? Is that the type of society we want? Do we expect accidents to never happen and want to criminalize anything less than perfection? We have manslaughter laws that allow for criminal penalties when a person's negligence rises to a level of criminality. Accidents happen. Accidents that result in terrible injury and death are tragic. But humans aren't perfect; we get distracted--by things other than cell phones. Not every accident is criminal in nature; and for that we have a civil system that--while focused on monetary compensation--is simply the best we've come up with beyond demanding blood satisfaction. I guess I wish I understood the debate better.
- oxryly1 9y agoYou're getting the gist of it. Governments and advocates have already shifted away from the term "accident" and instead use the term "collision". The idea is that nothing is truly accidental and causes can always be assessed. Think of the 5 whys. Sometimes a driver is at fault, and since drivers are the ones controlling multiple tons of metal at high speeds any fault there is multiplied by that potentiality. That's my take at least.
- closeparen 9y ago"The society we want" expressed in this kind of article is one where public policy actively discourages (or at least doesn't go so far out of its way to encourage) driving. "Humans aren't perfect" - so they shouldn't be permitted to drive. If draconian liability terrifies people into riding the bus, that's victory. The state has effectively carved out an exception to the murder statutes because "hey, shit happens, humans aren't perfect behind the wheel." Challenging that is perfectly reasonable, especially if you don't accept that driving is or should be a necessary component of civilization.
- rwz 9y agoI generally agree with all you're saying, but it seems like in this particular situation the driver was using the phone the whole time and therefore her negligence rose to a level of criminality and therefore it should be treated as manslaughter.
- fencepost 9y ago2014 article by the way. This is something that's going to change slowly until legislators start rising bikes to work (not holding my breath). It's also something that may get worse - at least currently it's often possible to hear approaching cars due to engine noise. Quieter cars will make it harder for even fully alert riders to avoid approaching vehicles (I'm not implying that it's the riders' responsibility to avoid being hit, but it may be the reality).
- hamandcheese 9y agoAt higher speeds I believe road noise from tires is the dominating noise factor.
- axus 9y agoWouldn't this lead to cycling on streets being outlawed? Should it?
- another35 9y agoIt is a crime when you do it by purpose, not if it is an accident. A cyclist could kill a pedestrian as well in an unfortunate accident, should we treat that as a crime?
- richk449 9y ago> It is a crime when you do it by purpose, not if it is an accident. This statement doesn't seem to be consistent with the law in the US. Involuntary Manslaughter is a crime, and it explicitly covers cases in which the crime was not committed on purpose.
- WkndTriathlete 9y agoIn some cases, yes. Piloting a vehicle on motorways - regardless of type - is a privilege that carries a certain level of responsibility. If someone in a vehicle can't be bothered to exhibit that level of responsibility and kills someone else who was exhibiting that level of responsibility then it should be a crime.
- vec 9y ago> A cyclist could kill a pedestrian as well in an unfortunate accident, should we treat that as a crime? Yeah, probably. If you're operating a dangerous piece of equipment the onus is on you to do it safely. Bikes are more dangerous than shoes, cars are more dangerous than bikes, and commercial vehicles are more dangerous than cars. It's not actually that difficult to drive safely around cyclists. Go the speed limit, pay attention, and don't pass unless you can do so safely. Yes, this means sometimes you will go 15 in a 45mph zone for a couple of blocks. If someone finds that burdensome enough to risk killing someone else then I have no problem calling that criminal neglect.
- Zak 9y agoI injured a cyclist with my car when I was 18. I wasn't punished, and I don't think I should have been. The cyclist ran a red light on a busy 4-lane road with turn lanes, a 45 mph speed limit and frontage roads. A box van in the left turn lane made it impossible for me to see him until he entered my lane. His leg was broken in three places and he spent six months in the hospital; something taller than the sports car I was driving probably would have killed him. He was fined for running a red light. I don't think anybody should be criminally punished purely due to a bad outcome when they were acting with due care. Driving negligently is another matter entirely, and at a minimum, those who do it should be prevented from driving for a time.
- FireBeyond 9y agoI think your example shows perfectly well why you shouldn't be charged, and why she (probably) should - you were driving with due care, other party was negligent, whereas she (it's heavily implied) was on her phone at the time of the accident (and after).
- rl3 9y ago>To the three of them, it appeared as if Norton was trying to move her car to the side of the road. But in the process, she drove over Morgan’s head, with her right front tire placed squarely on top." What the fuck. What's even the best way to proceed in that situation? I know everyone screamed at the driver to back up, but to me that sounds extremely dangerous, especially with a front or all-wheel drive vehicle. Having the hysterical fool that managed to run over the victim a second time continue to operate the car with the victim's head under the tire is crazy on the face of it, even if it was perhaps the best course of action for that particular situation. If there's enough bystanders, lifting the vehicle and following it up with a short drag of the victim from under the tire almost seems better, spinal injury immobilization concerns be damned. Probably not enough people to lift in this particular case however, and most of the damage had probably already been done at that point. I also can't help but wonder how much worse similar situations could get if firearms came into play. At what point is it legally justifiable for an uncompliant driver that keeps running over a victim to be shot? I'd say most juries would likely acquit for a third time, and circumstances somewhat similar to this instance could be trial of the century material. That might sound absurd, but there's the argument that attempting to physically remove a continually-uncompliant wreckless driver would not only waste precious time, but may cause them to panic—hitting the gas and inflicting grevious harm to the victim. The driver could concievably be drunk and belligerent, for example. Furthermore, it could be argued that the firearm user was hysterical themselves: even the coolest customer in the world might snap when the tire of some idiot's car is resting on their immediate family member's head, because they were just run over again.
- interfixus 9y agoIt sometimes is, and often should be. However! The one cyclist I have been centimeters from killing or causing grievous bodily harm ought not to have counted against me, even had I been a tad less dexterous with brakes and steering. Some young woman, ears plugged into some iDevice, running a red light at full speed. Not joking about the centimeters. She would have been toast under the Toyota HiAce I was driving. The girl continued, apparently without even registering the close scrape she just had. I chased her down and delivered the shit sermon of the century. She appeared non-comprehending and utterly indifferent. Not claiming this to be typical cyclist behavior, but alas, it's not all that uncommon either. I am a sometime truck driver, and believe me, I know the terror of crowded city traffic, right turns, and cyclists. Some drivers are squarely to blame when the shit hit the fan, or the front wheel the cyclist, but some are most certainly not, and may suffer undeservedly for the rest of their lives. No, I am not reckless. I have done an awful lot of professionel driving, and haven't had an accident since 1983 when someone from a sideroad disregarded a stop sign. By the way, I am in full favour of also potentially criminalising hitting an animal. Most roadkills would be easily avoided, if people would just pay some goddamn attention to driving while driving.
- goda90 9y agoI think criminalizing hitting an animal is a terrible idea. Pedestrians, other drivers, and cyclists can be unpredictable, but more often than not they are within a certain range of expected behavior. Not so with animals. Driving late evening, with high beams on, no one else on the straight road, and right around the speed limit, I came upon a large herd of deer. I slowed down and kept a close eye on them. A small group decided to go from standing to running literally as I was passing them, and one grazed my right rear door with its butt as it did a 180 next to my car. They are not predictable and no amount of attention would prevent that. That's not mentioning the small animals that can be very hard to see.
- interfixus 9y agoI know it's tricky. Nevertheless, it's our damn duty to keep our eyes on the road - at all times. Living far out in the countryside, I see a lot of roadkill, deer included, but have yet to hit an animal, even though I leave home every morning long before daybreak. Cats and hedgehogs really are avoidable by any competent driver.
- peterwwillis 9y agoBecause humans suck ass at preventing harm. When cars were first introduced, they were implicitly allowed free roam over streets that were full of pedestrians, horses and carriages. They injured so many people they stopped counting, and each month would bring dozens of deaths. Only after enough people had died did they invent stop signs, traffic signals, lane markers, and one-way streets. They had to create new police departments to enforce the law on the road, and new courts to process offenses. They still didn't have mandatory driver education, brake lights, or posted speed limits. Left hand turns were difficult, drinking and driving was common, and people didn't understand why taking a corner at high speed might flip a car over. There were literally decades of people (mostly children) killed by automobiles on a regular basis, usually by reckless drivers and exacerbated by a lack of planning. And yet, even though some drivers would be pulled from their cars by angry mobs, nobody seemed to question whether all people should even be allowed to drive a car. Rules like crossing the street at designated intersections were created to put responsibility on pedestrians for their safety. By the mid-1920s, after two and a half decades of driving, we finally adopted national laws regarding driving, with driver education coming in the 1930's. Can you imagine if we let just anyone fly a plane? The sheer scope of the damage done makes even the idea laughable. But once the technology becomes cheap and available, it will happen, and we'll run into the same stupid problems. Because we suck at keeping people safe. Once automated cars become reliable and widespread, we're probably going to outlaw driving yourself, because it literally makes no sense to give a human total control over a two ton mass of steel hurtling down the road next to pedestrians and cyclists with no protection whatsoever (a curb is a guide, not protection). I mean, we don't even install metal bollards around cycling paths or sidewalks.
- _jal 9y agoIt was actually a fascinating early example of mass-media propaganda. Since the rule for centuries previously was that everyone had equal access to the roads, they had to repurpose a slur and frame the automotive road-takeover as progress over the yokels. Lots of lessons there that can be taken in a number of different ways. One bit of the history here, google will give you a lot more: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26073797 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26073797
- 9y ago
- throw7 9y agothings are slowly changing. this guy was recently convicted for 2nd degree manslaughter: http://gothamist.com/2017/09/25/matthew_von_ohlen_conviction.php http://gothamist.com/2017/09/25/matthew_von_ohlen_conviction... The joke in nyc is, after a cycling accident, nypd will be out in force ticketing bicyclists the day after.
- wilburTheDog 9y agoThe claim that "it's an accident and accidents just happen" is spurious. When you are in control of something that can easily cause the death or great bodily harm of another it is your duty to be vigilant and follow the rules to prevent accidents. The issue is much clearer in the gun owner community. If your gun discharges when you don't intend it to it's negligence, not an accident. Negligent Discharge is a common term and when it happens it is universally agreed that it was the owners fault because they didn't follow one of Cooper's rules, or were otherwise irresponsible. To say that someone driving a car has less responsibility than someone holding a gun is irrational, since they both can cause the death of others when used carelessly. It is true, however, that the other party can cause an accident. If someone runs out from the bushes in front of you on the freeway, it's clearly their fault when they get hit. But if you're texting on your cell phone and you run over a cyclist because of your own inattention, that's not an accident. That's your own negligence and should be treated as such.