3 ms·
The inflation hypothesis is too important an issue for cosmology to be dismissed as an issue of the usage of terms defined in a single paragraph. No great harm
by mannykannot 9y ago
The inflation hypothesis is too important an issue for cosmology to be dismissed as an issue of the usage of terms defined in a single paragraph. No great harm comes from calling it a theory, and nothing of importance is settled by instead calling it a hypothesis or conjecture.
Nevertheless, the article was prompted by a spat between scientists over just that issue. What this article does, however, is to lift the curtain and give us a look at what the real issues are: it is a debate about whether inflation is failing in its bid to become established science, and whether it is time to give up on it, or at least look more earnestly for and at alternatives.
For someone who is not a scientist, but who is familiar with the history of science and the works of Popper and Kuhn, it might seem that the distinctions between conjecture, hypothesis and theory are both clear-cut and important, but the fact is that when science is done (as opposed to being written about afterwards), there is a good deal of uncertainty, and sometimes confusion, with many false starts, dead-ends and half-understood truths.
- badosu 9y ago> No great harm comes from calling it a theory, and nothing of importance is settled by instead calling it a hypothesis or conjecture. It's fine to believe in this, however one must wonder why it is that an individual may hold String Theory to the same standard as General Relativity or Evolution, and when finally it is observed that String Theory is not the case (or some other Theory gets trendy) this individual loses credibility on Science as a whole. - Just the other day you scientists had a theory that the universe was expanding!! How can I believe in your other theories? It should not be required to the casual curious reader to understand this distinction. A notable scientist on the other hand, specially one that has visibility, carries some responsability when (s)he writes about such matters.
- mannykannot 9y agoYou have a point, though in English, we already have that problem with the difference between 'theory' in general usage, and in science.