5 ms·
The interviewer, who has remained heroically calm in the face of Diola’s verbal barrage, is not able to move the encounter out of stalemate, and eventually his
by mistermann 9y ago
The interviewer, who has remained heroically calm in the face of Diola’s verbal barrage, is not able to move the encounter out of stalemate, and eventually his bosses replace him. When the new interviewer takes a seat, Diola repeats his promise to talk “openly and honestly” to the right person, and resumes his inquisitorial stance. “Why are you asking me these questions?” he says. “Think carefully about your reasons.”
The new interviewer does not answer directly, but something about his opening speech triggers a change in Diola’s demeanour. “On the day we arrested you,” he began, “I believe that you had the intention of killing a British soldier or police officer. I don’t know the details of what happened, why you may have felt it needed to happen, or what you wanted to achieve by doing this. Only you know these things Diola. If you are willing, you’ll tell me, and if you’re not, you won’t. I can’t force you to tell me – I don’t want to force you. I’d like you to help me understand. Would you tell me about what happened?” The interviewer opens up his notebook, and shows Diola the empty pages. “You see? I don’t even have a list of questions.”
“That is beautiful,” Diola says. “Because you have treated me with consideration and respect, yes I will tell you now. But only to help you understand what is really happening in this country.”
This reinforces my belief that there is a sincere, rational (whether you agree or not) reasoned motivation for terrorist attacks, at least in some cases. We in the West just aren't interested in listening to those who we don't agree with.
- gadders 9y agoI'm sure there is, in their eyes. But if the price of compliance with it is unacceptable, that doesn't move us any further forward.
- nf05papsjfVbc 9y agoMaking an effort to understand in no way implies moving in the direction of compliance.
- brazzy 9y agoUnderstanding someone's motivation has nothing to do with compliance, unless you've already made up your mind that the other side is a comic book villain and their motivation is to be evil for evil's sake. In reality, understanding someone's motivation can lead you to discover factors that influence it which you can change without doing anything unacceptable or even detrimental to you.
- netsharc 9y agoHear hear. Meanwhile a lot of people are really reductionist due their lack of critical thinking. "They're evil because of the book they believe in, we should ban that religion!" (as if that will fix all the problems...). I find the work of Scott Atran in explaining the motivations of Islamic extremists (so we can also reduce/end it) really good: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/15/terrorists-isis https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/15/terror...
- mc32 9y agoCouldn't the same be said for every mass murderer? Columbine to Vegas. They all have some grievance, real or made up, I don't think understanding those grievances get us closer to understanding them on order to head of such reactions. Columbine, tons of kids get bullied, very few decide to take maximum revenge.
- mistermann 9y agoMaybe I'm reading too much into it, but based on those words I got a distinct impression that this person was fairly intelligent and well spoken, which cannot be said about all mass murderers.
- mc32 9y agoNot all but some are. Ted Kaczynski, while not a mass murderer, had the potential to be if his devices had been more powerful, or everyone's favorite mass murderer, the Che. They're not usually dumb.
- 0xfeba 9y agoTed Kaczynski is kind of in his own category.
- icebraining 9y agoChe is accused of killing dozens. The guy he helped remove from power - and which was backed by the US - killed thousands. Maybe he actually had a point?
- srean 9y agoKissinger would certainly qualify.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- olau 9y agoColumbine: so you do something to prevent kids from getting bullied and have fewer mass-murdering students as a result? Seems like a good example to me. In general, how can you fix something you don't understand? I've never understood the "let's just punish people and forget about it" attitude (not saying that's what you're saying, just that it seem like a fairly typical attitude). It seems really dangerous to me.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoInteresting how the parent is being downvoted for writing "This reinforces my belief that there is a sincere, rational (whether you agree or not) reasoned motivation for terrorist attacks, at least in some cases". Those downvotes prove the point.
- mistermann 9y agoWell, I always get at least one free downvote from someone who seems to follow me around.
- panic 9y agoIt's not hard to construct a reasoned motivation for anything you might want to do. That doesn't mean it's worth listening to.
- mistermann 9y agoWhether you genuinely want it to stop determines whether it's worth listening to, and there's a lot of people whose income depends on it not stopping.
- walshemj 9y agoModern "rational" terrorists for example the IRA deliberately chose bombing targets mainly for economic reasons as mass killings of "civilians" turned off their supporters not least those in the USA. I am not sure that ISIS et all are rational by mainstream muslim belief