42 ms·
People who organize self-righteous outrage mobs to ban whatever is "degrading the fabric of society" this week have a habit of doing more damage to society than
by closeparen 9y ago
People who organize self-righteous outrage mobs to ban whatever is "degrading the fabric of society" this week have a habit of doing more damage to society than whatever it was you thought you were protecting it from.
When self-righteous outrage mobs believe they have moral authority and are drumming up support for authoritarian interventions is when it's most important to challenge them forcefully. Even if an intervention is necessary in the end, it should be the product of a healthy debate and not an outrage mob railroading through its initial whims.
- musage 9y agoHow is "but it's optional" a forceful challenge or a healthy debate?
- closeparen 9y agoIt isn't - it's lazy and inarticulate - but pokemongoaway is complaining about the general theme of people challenging the scope or severity of a problem. There is a pretty significant difference between "$villian is doing $bad_thing to people" and "$villian is providing people the option to do $bad_thing to themselves and they are taking it." That's worth pointing out, particularly when $bad_thing is to read opposition news.
- musage 9y agoIt's nowhere near that clear cut. http://www.radiohamburg.de/Nachrichten/Deutschland-und-die-Welt/Panorama/2017/Oktober/Es-ist-wieder-soweit-Langenscheidt-kuert-das-Jugendwort-2017 http://www.radiohamburg.de/Nachrichten/Deutschland-und-die-W... One of the "unwords" nominated for 2017 is "sozialtot". That's "socially dead" as a synonym for not having a Facebook account. As for Google, when everybody has their email at google I can craft my packets by hand, Google will still slurp them up. But oh, it's all optional, that goes without saying so it has to be said all the damn time. > particularly when $bad_thing is to read opposition news. You don't even know if "and their use is purely optional." refers to even one word more than the headline. If it does, you don't get to pick and chose that conveniently. The article also contains sentences such as > All of them are making decisions about who gets a digital megaphone and who should be unplugged from the web. Where does people doing something to themselves even figure into that? We're still at that part where someone blamed the victim and you're contorting to excuse that as something noble at heart, if lazy and inarticulate.
- pokemongoaway 9y agoExactly, unwillingness to engage in proper debate is more of an authoritarian strategy than my line or questioning.
- musage 9y agoI think it's projection of the negative traits of what one is subservient to on those who see through it.
- pokemongoaway 9y agoSo I'm the authoritarian for questioning a platform that censors non-PC content, and whose CEO plans to run for president of the US? There's plenty of evidence that Google has done the same via YouTube.
- closeparen 9y agoThe specific criticism in this article is that Facebook hasn't done enough to censor non-PC content (i.e. permitted the use of its platform for right-wing activism).