4 ms·
It's a brilliant trilogy in a shitty packaging. From a personal recommendation elsewhere: Pros: - the premise is good - many of the plot twists are good or
by dmitriid 9y ago
It's a brilliant trilogy in a shitty packaging.
From a personal recommendation elsewhere:
Pros:
- the premise is good
- many of the plot twists are good or brilliant
- many problems described are obvious in hindsight, but something you would never think about
Cons:
- Writing is uneven. Some parts you sail through, some parts make you physically cringe
- Many (too many) parts are "here's a scientific theory I learned about, let me give you a brief Wikipedia-style description. (Contrast with Blindsight where explanation of theories used is done in the appendix to the book, and is an interesting read on its own)
- No person in the history of this world has ever spoken like characters in the book. Dialogs are just people explaining things to each other
- Some things are introduced "just because". Otherwise the crises in the book couldn't be solved (e.g. it's assumed that the book talks about now and suddenly there are advanced nanomaterials and working hibernation)
All in all:
It's a very solid "hard" science fiction book which could be absolutely brilliant. But it's greatness is greatly reduced by the language and structure.
- coldtea 9y ago>Many (too many) parts are "here's a scientific theory I learned about, let me give you a brief Wikipedia-style description. So? Doesn't sound that different from 90% of classic sci-fi, especially Asimov. >- No person in the history of this world has ever spoken like characters in the book. Dialogs are just people explaining things to each other Ditto.
- Armisael16 9y ago> So? Doesn't sound that different from 90% of classic sci-fi, especially Asimov. That doesn’t make it good writing.
- coldtea 9y agoNo, but it means it can still be good sci-fi. Sci-fi was never about the writing, in the way hi-brow literature was. Heck, it started from pulp magazines aimed at teenagers.