7 ms·
I wonder how long it would take for Google to spend an extra $1 Billion by bringing janitorial, food service, and other non-technical jobs in-house instead of c
by brudgers 9y ago
I wonder how long it would take for Google to spend an extra $1 Billion by bringing janitorial, food service, and other non-technical jobs in-house instead of contracting it out to the lowest bidder.
To put it in perspective, $1 Billion is 10,000 times $100,000. Or 1000 $100,000/year jobs for ten years before discounting for the time value of money. Instead, big chunks of the money will get siphoned off to administrators and technical instructors and computer manufacturers and lots of other areas that already have plenty of money.
A billion dollars is less than half the annual budget of University of Nebraska for serving ~50,000 students [1]. Back of envelope turns $1 Billion into ~22,000 student years which is in the same people-helped ballpark as the 10,000 worker years, with the difference being that those 10,000 worker years come with actual jobs at $100,000 a year. And the 10,000 worker years are offset by the current cost of contracting out the work and the value that work returns to Google's bottom line.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Nebraska_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Nebraska_system
- fraserharris 9y agoThey aren't doing this for charity - they are doing it to ensure a steady supply of technical hires. Technical jobs are profit centers; non-technical contracted services are cost centers.
- samfisher83 9y agoThey are getting tons of apps from top schools like harvard, stanford, etc. I don't think they will have any problem hiring people. Maybe this would help some small company a lot more that can't afford pay google salaries. Also If you believe the Pareto principle most of people at google probably aren't that important to their successes.
- losteric 9y agoTheir goal is to increase the supply and diversity of good engineers, likely decreasing salaries in the long run. It's about damn time!
- closeparen 9y agoGoogle could cut salaries by half or more while delivering equal or better quality of life if it built substantial engineering presence in cheap cities. Education is a wickedly complicated problem compared to not being in California.
- shados 9y agoThey actually do have problems hiring enough. They get tons of applications, but the vast majority are not worth looking at. The people from top schools are in high demand, and Google no longer has monopoly on cool tech workspaces with free lunches and random expensive perks. They have plenty of openings and they harass qualified people trying to poach them just as hard as everyone else. And since they actually DO have some unique challenges, they sometimes actually DO need people who know more than Rails CRUD apps, which makes things even trickier.
- samfisher83 9y agoIt seems the only stories you hear of them are interviewing people and then ghosting them. If they actually cared about hiring people you figure at least they would treat their candidates better. In my experience even amazon has been more on the ball with the recruiting process.
- shados 9y agoI'm not particularly fond of Google or the way they interview, but I've lived just a few blocks from their Cambridge office (so almost every engineer I know around here has interviewed there at one point or another). Aside for their criterias and interview questions which I find absurd (but that's subjective, I know a bunch of people who think they're fine), I haven't heard much that was really wrong with it aside for obviously underqualified candidates being brought in and then leaving pissed off after bombing it. The reality is that in this industry right now, unless what you're doing is little webapps with REST apis that store/retrieve data and not much else, hiring people is hard. All the somewhat large companies have 100+ openings at any given time and the majority of candidates are code monkeys. My current employer is doing decently and our reputation seems to allow us to get a steady stream of above average people applying, but there's still so many openings. Only so much you can do.
- ryguytilidie 9y ago>They are getting tons of apps from top schools like harvard, stanford, etc. I don't think they will have any problem hiring people. You're outright dismissing the idea that hiring is difficult for Google? You know they have over a thousand recruiters working for them, right?
- evanlivingston 9y agoDon't forget that if they increase the supply of technical jobs, they get to drive down the cost of those technical hires.
- sulam 9y agoI think I know what you meant to say, but what you typed is logically wrong. s/jobs/workers/
- nbanks 9y agoEven if google doesn't hire most of the people who graduate, having more people who can do tech jobs could help increase the supply and stop salaries from inflating more.
- jondubois 9y agoThe thing about hiring more software developers than you need is that it just adds complexity to the project without adding any new features. Big companies are terrible at this. As companies add more engineers, the engineers become less productive, then managers get worried and so they 1. Hire more engineers and 2. introduce new project management tools and methodologies to the company which lowers productivity even more but which creates an illusion of progress for idiotic upper management — Over time managers and engineers get used to lower levels of productivity as it keeps declining and the company keep hiring more and more engineers whose engineering skills themselves keep declining from being poorly used.
- speedplane 9y ago> As companies add more engineers, the engineers become less productive This is definitely true, but it's a necessary evil. If you want to build something small, you can do it with a super efficient tiger team. But if you want something huge, you need a massive inefficient team, even if each additional engineer is only 1/10th as efficient as the engineer in the tiger team. This is explained, with real-life examples, in the classic Mythical Man Month.
- synicalx 9y agoI guess other than wanting a continuing supply of in-country tech's to hire (as others have touched on), it sort of comes back to the old "give a man a fish" vs "teach him to fish" shenanigans. They could hire a bunch of janitors, who are already employed anyway, and essentially just transfer that $1b directly into their pockets but at the end of the day they're still going to be janitors. By investing that some amount of money into education though, they're enabling them to go off and achieve something more meaningful that they wouldn't otherwise have been able to do.
- dvanduzer 9y agoIf they brought that support staff in-house, wouldn't it be easier to teach them how to fish?
- synicalx 9y agoPossibly, but I wouldn't think it's likely that every janitor is going to want to be a programmer. Whereas if you invest money in a school that teaches programming, there's a good chance that most of the people attending that school will want to be a programmer. But you make a good point though, with even a fraction of that budget + maybe a little time investment from their staff, they could create some great opportunities for their otherwise non-technical employees.
- baursak 9y agoThis implies that janitor is an inherently inferior job that deserves lower pay. It might be true, but in my opinion an average janitor is more beneficial to society than an average programmer. More to the point though, what happens when a janitor learns to code and gets a coding job? You still need a janitor!
- losteric 9y agoDirect vs indirect utility. Janitors are directly beneficial to a small number of people. The typical Google engineering is indirectly and marginally beneficial to millions.
- j45 9y agoI suspect 1 billion in the hands of a google will go much further than an academic institution.