3 ms·
I'm pretty skeptical of traditional calorie counting, but wouldn't your experiment be simply explained by the 5x difference in caloric content between the two?
by nkurz 16y ago
I'm pretty skeptical of traditional calorie counting, but wouldn't your experiment be simply explained by the 5x difference in caloric content between the two?
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=3+oz+walnuts http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=3+oz+walnuts
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=3+oz+white+rice http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=3+oz+white+rice
Wouldn't it be more fair to compare equal calories rather than equal weights? I'd have to guess that eating 15 oz of rice might have a significant appetite suppressing effect as well.
Or maybe I'm not understanding the point of the experiment. Are you simply suggesting that by eating a strangely distributed 1200 calories you can 'make it until dinner'? :)
- niels_olson 16y ago1 oz ~ 15 g 1 g carb ~ 3.4 kcal 1 g fat ~ 9 kcal 3 oz fat ~ 405 kcal 3 oz carb ~ 153 kcal 405 / 153 ~ 2.65 That's assuming the nuts are pure fat. They're actually about 1:1:1 fat:protein:carb => 246 kcal, or a ratio of about 1.6 Ah, wait, yes, fair enough, the cooked rice would be much less calorically dense. Do let me withhold the water. Please cook 3 oz of rice. My basic point remains: fats satisfy, calorie for calorie, faster than carbs.
- nkurz 16y agoMy basic point remains: fats satisfy, calorie for calorie, faster than carbs. OK, I'd agree with that. I wasn't sure if that was the point you were trying to make, or whether you were saying something more subtle. And obviously there is a limit: eating 1250 kcal of cooked white rice (1 kg) would be rather a feat and would probably physically prevent you from eating any thing else for a while, whereas the same number of calories in the form of nuts (200 g) could sneak up on you! ps. Your numbers above are quite a bit off, as 1 oz is actually closer to 28 g, but you are forgiven as I'm guessing you are European and don't use ounces that often.