4 ms·
For a long time the anti-H1B segment has been critical of Big Tech for trying to undercut American tech workers instead in investing in citizens. So now they're
by Apocryphon 9y ago
For a long time the anti-H1B segment has been critical of Big Tech for trying to undercut American tech workers instead in investing in citizens. So now they're investing in the wrong citizens?
- twoquestions 9y agoHardly, especially if they execute aggressively on the "grow future client businesses" bit. I'll admit that part of my suspicion is rooted in self-interest, but if demand for my labor grows faster than other people can supply it I'll still win out (along with many others).
- zzzcpan 9y agoAbundance of cheap labor allows to "grow future client businesses", not the other way around. Cheap labor is key here, no matter where it comes from.
- UncleMeat 9y agoI swear, many of the HN crowd seems like they'd be happiest if they were the only developer on the planet.
- klipt 9y agoWell obviously, think of how well I'd be paid! /s
- vkou 9y agoYou should ask taxi drivers about how they feel about millions of people getting paid peanuts to drive for Lift and Uber. Or lawyers about how they feel about millions of people with law degrees unable to find work as lawyers. Or Physics PHDs about how they feel driving a cab^wUber. Or musicians, who live off selling t-shirts. Why do you think supply and demand does not apply to the IT labour market?
- UncleMeat 9y agoBecause labor generates additional demand. There isn't fixed demand for software engineers that persists across all time. The demand for engineers has grown over the last fifty years.
- nova22033 9y agoThere are a LOT of people in tech who are really insecure about their own jobs. They see any move like this as a plot by bigcorp to undermine their job prospects. Training kids to code? Yup..threat to their own job.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>There are a LOT of people in tech who are really insecure about their own jobs. If the rest of the job market looked like it did in the 1950s, sure - no problem. I don't see any reason to feel particularly secure when this is what's going on outside of tech though: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/28/adjunct-professors-homeless-sex-work-academia-poverty https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/28/adjunct-prof... >They see any move like this as a plot by bigcorp to undermine their job prospects. Either tech bigcorp is concerned about their bottom line or they aren't. If they are, then wouldn't it be economically rational to try and reduce their largest expense - developer wages? I wonder sometimes if people are really naive enough to think that Mark Zuckerberg is trying to "reform immigration" or "get CS taught in primary schools" out of the goodness of his heart.
- nova22033 9y agoWhat does the plight of adjunct professors have to do with the job market for software professionals? >I wonder sometimes if people are really naive enough to think that Mark Zuckerberg is trying to "reform immigration" or "get CS taught in primary schools" out of the goodness of his heart. First a non sequitur and now a strawman? I don't think Zuckeberg lets me use facebook out of the goodness of his heart either...
- crdoconnor 9y ago>What does the plight of adjunct professors have to do with the job market for software professionals? I see tens of thousands of (often desperate) people trying to get in to the profession because that's what it's like on the outside. So far demand has outstripped supply, but I can see demand collapsing if/when VC dries up and demand remaining the same while people continue to flood in to the profession. That is, over time, I expect the job market for software professionals to end up more like the job market for adjunct professors than vice versa. >First a non sequitur and now a strawman? I don't think Zuckeberg lets me use facebook out of the goodness of his heart either... Right. So you think Facebook is run for advertising dollars and his other "charitable" ventures (e.g. to reform immigration) are run as an attempt to undermine developer wages?