5 ms·
I'm under the hypothesis that (good) game developers know how to talk to people (or at least how to present things to people) because part of game design is thi
by derefr 9y ago
I'm under the hypothesis that (good) game developers know how to talk to people (or at least how to present things to people) because part of game design is thinking about how to manipulate people's emotions into wanting to (or even being eager to!) face a challenge you've set out for them.
It's similar but not identical to the reasoning for actors and directors to be good entertainers and interviewers. Those folks constantly think about manipulating people's emotions in general, but game design is completely focussed on just manipulating people into excitement or flow states — and that just so happens to be the emotion you (usually) want people to have in reaction to a presentation: the feeling of "I'm going to go out— and buy their thing —and change the world."
- Tarq0n 9y agoCarmack is more of a game engine engineer than a game designer, as evidenced by the lacklustre design of id games after Romero left.
- erikj 9y agoQuake 3 Arena is still one of the best multiplayer shooters ever, so I can't agree with your statement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 9y agoWhile surely being a marvel of software engineering and level design, it had nothing in common with Quake I and II. It is not my intent to be critical here, but QA3 felt like a circus, especially compared with other multiplayer shooters such as the original Unreal Tournament, which had a wonderful mysterious atmosphere to it.
- wlesieutre 9y agoI was just playing something recently and thought "This feels like an Unreal Tournament Space Castle." Can't remember what game it was. UT99 had some fantastic level design. Facing Worlds, Phobos, HyperBlast, Deck 16, Coret, etc.
- failrate 9y agoQ3 is intentionally stripped down. Primarily due to Carmack's direction. Iirc from his old plan files.
- AgentME 9y agoIt has great game mechanics, but in all other manners of design it feels like a hodgepodge of unrelated assets thrown together. Quake 1 had a similar problem early in development, but they managed to tie it together. Quake 3 didn't even bother with a true singleplayer campaign, which seems like a winning move in hindsight, but at the time it was a departure from the norm and I can't help but feel like it was a move they did out of necessity.
- porfirium 9y agoRomero did not leave, Carmack fired him, in his own words, for "not working hard enough."
- clebio 9y agoWhy the downvotes?
- sciurus 9y agoCitation: https://www.bluesnews.com/articles/carmackinterview.html https://www.bluesnews.com/articles/carmackinterview.html
- badsectoracula 9y agoEh, judging from the Masters of Doom book, i wouldn't take his words seriously considering the tension that existed at the time between the two and how Carmack basically burned out himself during Quake's development. Romero wasn't the only one who left id at the time.
- tapoxi 9y agoQuake III Arena (Graeme Devine) was a fantastic game, although Doom 3 and RAGE weren't particularly inspiring. Doom (2016) was released after Carmack left, but it's one of the best shooters they've made.
- puranjay 9y agoQ3 always suffered from the fact that it was released right around Unreal Tournament which was a far superior game, especially in level design.
- tapoxi 9y agoIts a matter of preference, I think. I was only able to play UT growing up, thanks to its software renderer, and finally played Q3 (Quake Live) in college. Q3 is more minimalist, which makes competitive play more interesting. Q3 has also maintained a competitive scene to this day where UTs seems to have fizzled out.
- mistermann 9y agoGreat perspective.
- vvanders 9y agoI think it's less this and more that being able to present this information is the mark of a really good technical leader.
- yllaucaj 9y agoI like that idea. It's also true that a field like game development, which is both collaborative and interdisciplinary, pretty much requires excellent communication skills. Being a game designer is less about having amazing "ideas" or "vision" (everyone has those) and more about your ability to align everyone's ideas and vision in the same direction. Personally, I prefer to describe "thinking about manipulating people's emotions" as _empathy_, but that's just me.
- derefr 9y ago> Personally, I prefer to describe "thinking about manipulating people's emotions" as _empathy_, but that's just me. Empathy is the core skill, yes, but there's a sort of... I almost want to say an instinctual disgust? that people also have to overcome, when they want to turn empathy around to use it to change someone else's mind, rather than just using it to predict someone else's mind. You have to become at least a little bit of a sociopath, is maybe the problem. See, other people have different foundational beliefs—different axioms they're working from. To use "empathy aikido" on them—to come up with arguments that will convince them of something, not slowly and laboriously from logical first principles, but by building up quickly from what they already assume to be true—you have to be willing to make arguments that are true under their axioms, but not under yours. That is, you have to be willing to use arguments that you think are false, just because the person you're trying to convince will believe them. It feels weirdly like lying; like you're a politician swaying the populace with empty rhetoric. But you're not saying things that nobody would believe (if given long enough to think about them); you're instead just getting into the head of—empathizing with—the person who holds those axioms, and then saying things that you—as that person—really do believe. This is why, I think, there's a big divide between people who like or hate the idea of "salesmanship": some people fundamentally see it as lying, while other people fundamentally see it as empathizing. Personally, I think it can end up either way—some people "sell" an idea while holding back a bunch of facts that, under their axioms, are total deal-breakers. Others, though, "build a bridge" between their interlocutor's world-model and their own, using their arguments to help the other person build a world-model enough like their own that they can then present the facts that they believe to the listener, and the listener can understand them through the "consensus schema†" they built. † https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schema_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schema_(psychology) People who are said to have "reality distortion fields", I'm guessing, are just good at making those kind of points that build a consensus schema, that they can then state plain "facts" against which will seem—within the consensus schema—to be obvious, rather than having to convince you of each fact through argument. Despite the gnawing feeling that accepting that consensus schema into your brain is sort of an indoctrination into a cult, it's really the less ethically questionable of the two options, in my mind: the speaker doesn't have to say anything they don't actually believe (other than the arguments required to build the consensus schema.)