46 ms·
The worst thing about the Hyperloop concept is how it takes different smart people with slightly different assumptions about what is being described, how it sho
by kbenson 9y ago
The worst thing about the Hyperloop concept is how it takes different smart people with slightly different assumptions about what is being described, how it should work, and how it does work in the fields they are familiar with or experts in and the other fields they are only conversant in, and turns those people into rabid defenders of their own calculations that somehow lose the ability to reassess where mistakes might have been made. I'm not sure how or why this happens, because as far as I know none of this is theoretical science, it's just a matter of applying the principles accurately (which seems to be the sticking point). For example, here's a whole playlist of people arguing over the physics of it, which does devolve into name-calling at points.[1] There appears to be good science involved in the assessments though, but could be said for the most part about both parties. The interesting parts are where people step outside their areas of expertise and their unfamiliarity with the application of the principles causes mistakes.
1: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2KUz4c22UbZCco https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2K...