3 ms·
Strange how things have flipped. A mere 10 years ago or so, the sides in a statement like this would've been reversed, especially if it were on any other aspect
by _delirium 16y ago
Strange how things have flipped. A mere 10 years ago or so, the sides in a statement like this would've been reversed, especially if it were on any other aspect of human psychology or behavior:
She has stated that she believes sexual behavior is the result of accountable
personal choice rather than an inevitability deriving from deterministic forces.
The modern (post-WW2) academic left has generally been very opposed to deterministic explanations of human behavior that sap the subject of agency. For a long time, accusing someone of "genetic determinism" or "environmental determinism" or similar was an insult. But here someone is being accused of not believing in essentially a variety of genetic/environmental determinism.
It's strange that it even came up, though. No school I've been at does any sort of ideological vetting of its undergrads and masters students; masters students are barely noticed at all as they zip in and out in a year or two. (PhD students are more complicated, because to some extent it's joint research with an advisor, so if you have bitter disagreements with all the faculty, problems will ensue.)
- hga 16y agoOceania has always been at war with Eastasia.
- georgecmu 16y agoPersonally, I think this sort of ideological vetting in this case is justified. This girl is planning to be a school counselor somewhere, and chances are she would have to counsel LGBT kids. She made it clear that she would not accept their sexual identities, would consider them sinners destined for hell, and, chances are, would treat them accordingly. If her beliefs were truly personal and there would be reasonable doubt that they would not interfere with her work and duty toward the kids, this would be a non-issue. However, as it stands, she is likely to incur a lot of emotional damage to kids from the most vulnerable segment of school population.
- _delirium 16y agoI could buy that as a job requirement. I'm mostly uncomfortable how it's couched in language about determinism, as if believing in genetic/environmental determinism is now a prerequisite to get degrees. I'd actually be much more okay with an openly ideological test, like: a prerequisite to get this degree is a belief that LGBT kids are not immoral/etc. and ought to be treated respectfully [etc. etc.].
- hga 16y agoWhile I'm not familiar with the tenets of other Christian faiths, the Roman Catholic belief is that being LGBT is not immoral per se, but engaging in homosexual acts is. Which brings us to the issue of premarital/underage sex: it hardly matters whether it's hetro or homosexual now, does it? Should all Christians be removed from this field? Or should we consider that those who say "Hate the sin, love the sinner" just might be sincere? In which case "an openly ideological test" to simply treat people with respect is not so ideological after all. Whereas the grounds they are pushing, echoing my 1984 riff, ought to require frequent testing as the true ideology de jour changes.
- pfedor 16y agoOh, but with respect to other aspects of human behavior the things are still the other way around. From the article, another of her questionable beliefs was: She also has affirmed binary male-female gender, with one or the other being fixed in each person at their creation, and not a social construct or individual choice subject to alteration by the person so created. Clearly, the approved view would have been that whether you are male or female is a "social construct" and/or your individual choice, however whether you are gay or straight is hardwired.