3 ms·
Wait, who said that they need to compress the air all the way to Earth pressure? None of your critique makes sense without that assumption, and nowhere in your
by Robotbeat 9y ago
Wait, who said that they need to compress the air all the way to Earth pressure?
None of your critique makes sense without that assumption, and nowhere in your post do you say where that comes from.
- schiffern 9y ago> Wait, who said that they need to compress the air all the way to Earth pressure? No one. The Hyperloop alpha paper explicitly contradicts this assumption on page 18, where the flow diagram gives the compressor input at 99 Pa and the output at 2.1 kPa (a 21:1 pressure ratio). http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The Hyperloop alpha paper explicitly contradicts this assumption on page 18, where the flow diagram gives the compressor input at 99 Pa and the output at 2.1 kPa (a 21:1 pressure ratio) One standard atmosphere (atm) is defined at over 100,000 Pa [1]. The 21:1 pressure ratio in Figure 11 on page 18 is for the "passenger plus vehicle capsule" [2]. I'm talking about the tube. Going from 99 to 2.1 isn't hard. Going from 100,000 to 100 and then keeping it there is. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_(unit) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_(unit) [2] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- Robotbeat 9y agoBut that's no challenge at all. You're just describing a usual vacuum pump. And just a single-stage roughing pump (Harbor Freight, anyone?) can get down to less than 1 Pascal, so 100Pa is a piece of cake. That's only needed for slight leaks in the tube, not for the pod itself. Keep in mind that the absolute pressure difference is far less for Hyperloop than for a typical natural gas pipeline, and yet the latter can keep leaks to an absolute minimum in spite of thermal expansion, etc.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> You're just describing a usual vacuum pump Scaling is hard. The largest vacuum chamber we've built is a fraction of the size of the proposed Hyperloop. It was a very, very hard problem [1]. It's expensive, sucks up loads and loads of power and needs lots of thermal management, structural reinforcement and vacuum-off maintenance. > Keep in mind that the absolute pressure difference is far less for Hyperloop than for a typical natural gas pipeline Pipes are pressurized from the inside. See my comment from elsewhere in the thread on why vacuums are different [2]. All this said, I generally agree with you. I don't think building a giant vacuum is beyond current technological capability. I do think building one structurally sound and thermal-expansionwise stable enough to carry passengers at high speeds is. [1] http://teamcorporation.com/images/technical_documents/Space-Power-Facility-Capabilities-for-Space-Environmental-Testing-in-a-Single-Facility.pdf http://teamcorporation.com/images/technical_documents/Space-... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15459873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15459873
- hwillis 9y agoThat vacuum chamber has two sets of fifty foot tall doors. The hyperloop is an inch-thick welded steel tube. Pinholes are trivially detected by ultrasonic testers. There are no leaks. Even hydrogen and helium would take centuries to diffuse inside. The only problems are sealing the ends, which are a couple meters wide. The hyperloop as written was very challenging, but the engineering aspects are not. The practical building (grinding the inside, transporting the tubes, etc.) are significant. The financing is insane. The theory is not even particularly hard, much less at the level of a space elevator.
- schiffern 9y ago>The largest vacuum chamber we've built is a fraction of the size of the proposed Hyperloop. It was a very, very hard problem [1]. Do we really have to say that a long extruded tube that only has to maintain low vacuum is a lot simpler than the SPS? SPS: big thing made up of many custom one-off parts that runs at 1/380,000,000ths of an atmosphere and can blast test articles with intense simulated sunlight. Hyperloop tunnel: big thing made up of many identical parts that runs at 1/1,000ths of an atmosphere. >It's expensive, sucks up loads and loads of power I think they know that, don't you? There's no line-by-line breakdown, but the paper allocates $260 million for the station+pumps and 21 MW for electricity consumption (pumping, accelerating pods, and charging pod batteries). >needs lots of thermal management I agree that you need it, but what specific problem do you see? >Pipes are pressurized from the inside. See my comment from elsewhere in the thread on why vacuums are different [2]. You said a soda can is stronger when pressurized from the inside. That's true, but the obvious solution is to make it thicker than a soda can. :) The paper calls for 0.8-1.0 inch thick steel, which my math says is more than adequate.
- schiffern 9y agoAxial compressors aren't the only compressor design. Rotary vane compressors have no problem with those pressures. The internal pressure was chosen explicitly because it was easy to maintain with simple, single stage mechanical vacuum pumps (see Figure 13 on page 22). Heck, the first result on Amazon for "vacuum pump" goes down to 5 Pa. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B012CFTYX4/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B012CFTYX4/ Compare the Hyperloop to true "vacuum train" designs, which need to run at 1/1,000,000th of an atmosphere to mitigate sonic booms (an alternate way to get around the Kantrowitz limit). This requires multi-stage pumping with mechanical roughing, followed by turbomolecular pumps and cryopumping. That 1000x harder vacuum takes 1000x as much pumping power (not because the differential pressure is meaningfully different, but because you expel 1000x less air per stroke).