3 ms·

does anyone know a good oss alternative to unity that supports ios and android? i'm familiar with godot but i don't know how robust it is compared to unity.

earenndil 9y ago
Unreal isn't actually oss but source-available so works well enough. Why not try godot and see if it's robust enough for you? Another open-source engine you could look at is urho3d (it still supports 2d games).
- mlevental 9y ago
  what do you mean source available? can i get the source and compile it myself?
  - cweagans 9y ago
    Yes, but it's not "open", per se. You get access to the source, but you cannot distribute it.
    - mlevental 9y ago
      how do i get it? isn't the same the case for unity actually?
      - earenndil 9y ago
        https://github.com/epicgames/unrealengine https://github.com/epicgames/unrealengine. You have to register your github account with them on their website[1] to get access to it. This is not the case with unity. 1: https://www.unrealengine.com/register https://www.unrealengine.com/register
      - cweagans 9y ago
        You don't get source for Unity unless you pay a boatload of money.
MrLeap 9y ago
For 2d stuff, haxe is pretty good. If you have any Actionscript 3 experience, a lot of memories will come rushing back to you. I haven't tried Godot yet but it looks really compelling. I sure wish they didn't make up a new language to script with though, there are already so many good choices. :/
sprucely 9y ago
I've been following Godot for some time. Development of 3.0 is progressing nicely and looking to have some great features... C#, GDNative (script bindings for other languages: D, Rust, etc.), asset library, a more modern graphics pipeline My understanding is that those coming from Unity often get tripped up by Godot's scene/instancing system because it's somewhat different than how prefabs work. Subtrees in a scene can be broken out into a separate scene and instanced. Elements as basic as a bullet should be implemented as a scene and then instanced and customized as needed. A common sentiment I've seen is, once it "clicks," they can't imagine going back. I've only spent a few hours in Godot since recently cloning/building the master branch, and I already have a nice force-directed graph implemented. If it gets to a point where the number of graph nodes affects performance, I can move the force calculations from GDScript to cpp or another native option.
thatonechad 9y ago
For 2D games, GameMaker is good but has its own scripting language but the language is very similar to javascript.

earenndil 9y ago

Unreal isn't actually oss but source-available so works well enough. Why not try godot and see if it's robust enough for you? Another open-source engine you could look at is urho3d (it still supports 2d games).

mlevental 9y ago
what do you mean source available? can i get the source and compile it myself?
- cweagans 9y ago
  Yes, but it's not "open", per se. You get access to the source, but you cannot distribute it.
  - mlevental 9y ago
    how do i get it? isn't the same the case for unity actually?
    - earenndil 9y ago
      https://github.com/epicgames/unrealengine https://github.com/epicgames/unrealengine. You have to register your github account with them on their website[1] to get access to it. This is not the case with unity. 1: https://www.unrealengine.com/register https://www.unrealengine.com/register
    - cweagans 9y ago
      You don't get source for Unity unless you pay a boatload of money.

MrLeap 9y ago

For 2d stuff, haxe is pretty good. If you have any Actionscript 3 experience, a lot of memories will come rushing back to you. I haven't tried Godot yet but it looks really compelling. I sure wish they didn't make up a new language to script with though, there are already so many good choices. :/

sprucely 9y ago

I've been following Godot for some time. Development of 3.0 is progressing nicely and looking to have some great features... C#, GDNative (script bindings for other languages: D, Rust, etc.), asset library, a more modern graphics pipeline My understanding is that those coming from Unity often get tripped up by Godot's scene/instancing system because it's somewhat different than how prefabs work. Subtrees in a scene can be broken out into a separate scene and instanced. Elements as basic as a bullet should be implemented as a scene and then instanced and customized as needed. A common sentiment I've seen is, once it "clicks," they can't imagine going back. I've only spent a few hours in Godot since recently cloning/building the master branch, and I already have a nice force-directed graph implemented. If it gets to a point where the number of graph nodes affects performance, I can move the force calculations from GDScript to cpp or another native option.

thatonechad 9y ago

For 2D games, GameMaker is good but has its own scripting language but the language is very similar to javascript.