4 ms·
I agree. But one of the problems NICE finds is the variable quality of what "mindfulness" actually is. Can an app deliver mindfulness? Can an MP3? Can it be sel
by DanBC 9y ago
I agree. But one of the problems NICE finds is the variable quality of what "mindfulness" actually is. Can an app deliver mindfulness? Can an MP3? Can it be self-delivered? Is there a difference between group work and solo work? If a mental health professional gives a patient a link to HeadSpace has that MH professional delivered a mindfulness treatment?
And NICE are sometimes giving DO NOT recommendations for mindfulness, eg here:
https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg159/chapter/1-Recommendations https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg159/chapter/1-Recommendat...
> Do not routinely offer mindfulness-based interventions[3] or supportive therapy to treat social anxiety disorder.
The supporting evidence for that is here: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg159/evidence/full-guideline-pdf-189895069 https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg159/evidence/full-guideli...
- vidarh 9y agoI'm not surprised they recommend against it for social anxiety. I've dealt with (relatively low levels of) social anxiety myself, and I also do mindfulness meditation, and while I thing mindfulness can be useful in understanding the mental impulses ("why did I not say hi to that person even though I badly wanted to?") and have made me a lot more acutely aware of the impulses driving how I act in social situations, it alone has done nothing to alter that behavior or the anxieties around it. In my case my anxieties were limited enough that while I won't say I've completely gotten rid of it, I got over most it by applying my own gradual exposure - I spent months setting myself challenges of e.g. getting eye contact with and saying hi, or "how are you?" in "low stress" situations like to cashiers or other "captive" audiences. It not only reduced my anxieties but was a big eye opener in terms of social interactions in general (peoples responses changed dramatically). [note: I don't recommend people do this if they face severe anxiety - see a therapist; it worked for me, but probably largely because my anxiety was mild] I'd think mindfulness might be useful for someone with social anxiety after they have the actual anxiety under control, though, as a way to further improve social skills, just like for people without anxiety. But I'm not surprised it's not a good choice as a replacement for other therapy or drugs to get the anxiety itself under control. [EDIT: As an example of the awareness it brought to me, one thing I hate is making phone calls, and mindfulness has not stopped that, but one thing mindfulness has done was making me aware of avoidance behaviors, such as letting me more easily "catch myself out" when I use silly excuses for going to pointless lengths to e.g. seek out information online instead of making a two minute phone call; it didn't make me feel less anxious about the call but may have had a limited effect in making it more easily apparent to me which things I are worth addressing using other methods]