4 ms·
> I was introduced to mindfulness practice as a therapy for depression several years ago at my university. They were clear it was a new approach for clinical us
by DanBC 9y ago
> I was introduced to mindfulness practice as a therapy for depression several years ago at my university. They were clear it was a new approach for clinical use (though building on a long history of meditation) and that although the initial research results were promising it was still very much a developing area.
It would be great if that's the approach other people were taking. Not everyone does this. Some of them will push mindfullness as being risk free (for a small number of people it increases risk of self harm or death by suicide) and effective for most people (it's effective for some people, but we don't know how many people).
> For what it's worth, I've personally found it one of the more effective techniques I've been taught for relapse prevention.
Yes. This is why it's important to be honest. "This seems to work, and work well, for some people. It might work for you. You should try it, and if it doesn't work we'll talk about other options." is fine. But I know people who are being denied any other option.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> But I know people who are being denied any other option. Am I correct in guessing you are talking about a work setting, where the situation is similar to something like: "if you're overworked we're not going to address the root problem by lowering the amount of work to a sensible load, we're going to make you do more work in the form of mental exercises to strengthen your resilience, so we can burden you with more work!"?
- DanBC 9y agoNo. I'm talking about an English NHS health settting.
- vanderZwan 9y agoOh wow, I would expect a situation with proper health care professionals to be better than that. That sounds pretty bad.