3 ms·
They’ve hidden behind cookie sales for years, and outside that, I can’t tell you one thing that they do. You think Boy Scouts, you think Eagle scouts, tying kn
by mikestew 9y ago
They’ve hidden behind cookie sales for years, and outside that, I can’t tell you one thing that they do.
You think Boy Scouts, you think Eagle scouts, tying knots, and camping. Outdoorsy, can-do, and always prepared. The animal shelter at which I volunteer has benefitted from the multiple Eagle Scout projects that built needed equipment for us. You think Girl Scouts, you think Thin Mints. A Girl Scout could have built the agility equipment for that same animal shelter. Instead, the local GS troop did a water color wall painting. Way to go, you girls stay and decorate while the boys build useful stuff. That's a failure not only of marketing, but also of programming.
"You said you don't know jack about boating, how'd you know how to tie a bowline?"
"I was a Boy Scout."
That's my answer to a lot of "how'd you know...?" questions. And I'll bet not a week goes by that I don't use knowledge gained from Boy Scouts. From sharpening a kitchen knife to tying a timberline hitch for an ad hoc guy line, I wonder if even a day goes by that I don't use knowledge gained from scouts. Not to mention the leadership and mental attitude aspects.
I don't recall a woman ever answering "how'd you...?" with "I was a Girl Scout". Of the women I've questioned who were in Girl Scouts, I don't recall any that found it to be a particularly valuable experience.
Now, that's certainly anecdotal, and most likely very dated given my age. But GSA needs better PR than "we sell cookies", and they need the programs to match. I'm neutral on BSA accepting girls, but I'm disappointed that the GSA has failed girls such that it was needed to begin with.
- op00to 9y agoWhen I think of Boy Scout leadership, I think of religious loonies who have an irrational fear of gay and transgendered scouts and leaders.